Jets fan meltdown and QB discussion thread
- Thread starter Brewers888
- Start date
twinkie13
In transit, arriving late.
I thought he would look better at Ohio St and he has not in my opinion
twinkie13
In transit, arriving late.
Totally. And he isn’t Haskins, agree.
Haskins was a complete reach in the 1st round and I think Haskins is a reach super early in the draft
number2
Pretty much a regular
Maybe they need to switch colors? It could be a color thing.......
number2
Pretty much a regular
There’s only 1 ELIte QB that I know of.........
You are one of the very few then.
I know I was high on him before and after transfer.
95% of pundits/posters/tweeters thought he would be a bust.
number2
Pretty much a regular
Don’t they have someone name Cardale Jones? Then the QB turn wide receiver?
Buckeyes QBs don’t seem to do too well in the NFL.....
twinkie13
In transit, arriving late.
Look back 2 years. Everyone said he sucked (this is after sec championship game).
I said then he was a top 5 Heisman finalist the very next year.
Most laughed
Sure enough.
twinkie13
In transit, arriving late.
I know it seems like a pile on thread, I’m not doing that.
I actually wish I could pull it, I think I had a thread on Jalen Hurts and saying I think he could play pro ball better than most thought.
That one looks better today.
The Mahomes miss for me pretty much disqualifies my opinion anyway haha
I actually wish I could pull it, I think I had a thread on Jalen Hurts and saying I think he could play pro ball better than most thought.
That one looks better today.
The Mahomes miss for me pretty much disqualifies my opinion anyway haha
number2
Pretty much a regular
Didn’t Wentz go to the same school?
twinkie13
In transit, arriving late.
He’s just a winner/leader. Love his demeanor.
twinkie13
In transit, arriving late.
The other thing is this:
cant be said enough. What one deems as “good” in the NFL is a whole other debate.
Like for me, anyone that says Stanford isn’t “good” is crazy. Have to look at the whole team and what’s around.
Mark Sanchez to me, isn’t good. But he had a crazy defense and played in 2 AFC ship games( one for sure can’t recall)
cant be said enough. What one deems as “good” in the NFL is a whole other debate.
Like for me, anyone that says Stanford isn’t “good” is crazy. Have to look at the whole team and what’s around.
Mark Sanchez to me, isn’t good. But he had a crazy defense and played in 2 AFC ship games( one for sure can’t recall)
guaranteeed
Pretty much a regular
Fields was ahead of head and shoulders i think too coming into jorja
His body is build way different than haskins like you say, and his improvement as a thrower puts him in a different stratosphere than haskins, plus hes a legit threat to run
Fields comparison for me is what lamar is now with better accuracy
guaranteeed
Pretty much a regular
Totally depends on coaching tho
What if fields goes somewhere and he gets a beinemy or joe brady as his guy, no reason he couldn't have a better career
Even if hes not as pure or powerful a passer
guaranteeed
Pretty much a regular
Haskins body is built like that tom brady draft day photo
Fields is a UNIT
Fields is a UNIT
They were 1A and 1B
Fields has had makeshift olines for half the year and still put up ridiculous numbers.
Johnnyonthespot
CTG Regular
He did, but that's where the comparisons end
Although I have to say I am completely thrown by the play of Wentz post injury. He has played with injured players (wr/ol) for a long time. I still like him and want to understand his issue(s)
guaranteeed
Pretty much a regular
I really like this draft for QBs tho
Lance could be kyler with more talent as a pocket passer, but also the scrambling
Fields could be russ wilson imo eventually if he gets coached up and puts in the work, but for now he could be lamar with better accuracy
Lawrence is obviously a unicorn, like the sheriffs brains mixed with randall Cunninghams ability
Zach wilson is a poor man's pat mahomes, just in the style he plays
Trask even has a ton of arm talent, even if he moves like hes running in molasses
Mac jones in the right system could be a decent starter too
Or you wait till next year and take Howell or slovis
Lance could be kyler with more talent as a pocket passer, but also the scrambling
Fields could be russ wilson imo eventually if he gets coached up and puts in the work, but for now he could be lamar with better accuracy
Lawrence is obviously a unicorn, like the sheriffs brains mixed with randall Cunninghams ability
Zach wilson is a poor man's pat mahomes, just in the style he plays
Trask even has a ton of arm talent, even if he moves like hes running in molasses
Mac jones in the right system could be a decent starter too
Or you wait till next year and take Howell or slovis
twinkie13
In transit, arriving late.
See i wouldn’t risk that either.
guaranteeed
Pretty much a regular
Saw athletic one other day had that, fields lasted till 6
Zero chance
I know bengals will want that oregon LT, but if for some reason wilson goes too, someone's trading up with Bengals to take fields
twinkie13
In transit, arriving late.
See I don’t like Slovis. I take Howell way before
guaranteeed
Pretty much a regular
Wentz is gonna move on imo and come back strongHe did, but that's where the comparisons end
Although I have to say I am completely thrown by the play of Wentz post injury. He has played with injured players (wr/ol) for a long time. I still like him and want to understand his issue(s)
I have a feeling maybe chicago for him, could easily see him back as a top 10 qb next year
Johnnyonthespot
CTG Regular
Zach Wilson may have the talent but I'm not sure his personality translates. He acts weird to me. He seems like a peacock. You can have him. I will take Lance, I like Trask too
guaranteeed
Pretty much a regular
Howell is 1.1 next year no doubt imo
Johnnyonthespot
CTG Regular
I'm glad you feel that way. I like Pederson more than Nagy but a change will do him good
guaranteeed
Pretty much a regular
I think it's just any change will help
Like you say hes had no real talent, only reason hurts has done moderately ok is because he can run around, and not just get crushed by a pass rush
Add to that no real wide receiving threats in the last 2 years?
This guy was basically the mvp up until he tore his acl in the super bowl year
Chicago just sticks out cause I think they will be looking, they know he can play in weather, and need a proven qb. Could see the Pats interested and plenty others
twinkie13
In transit, arriving late.
Cam?
Johnnyonthespot
CTG Regular
Him on the Pats is something I hadnt thought of but like a great deal. That would be awesome
guaranteeed
Pretty much a regular
twinkie13
In transit, arriving late.
I’m asking. He a backup somewhere?
guaranteeed
Pretty much a regular
twinkie13
In transit, arriving late.
I’d take him and let him work in camp with a young guy or stack him next to a vet in case he goes down
all day
guaranteeed
Pretty much a regular
Ravens would be a nice spot.
wiseplayer
Pretty much a regular
I agree. He's garbage
Brewers888
Potential 2028 V.P. Selection
Would you be satisfied if Andy Dalton was your teams QB. I realize you are a Chiefs fan and have Mahomes but putting that aside would you be happy with Dalton as the QB or would you want and expect an upgrade. Personally I want my team to have an unquestioned top 10 QB in the league and I would always be looking to upgrade the position if the QB is not up to those standards.
Brewers888
Potential 2028 V.P. Selection
If Fields is your QB in the NFL you are never winning anything.
Brewers888
Potential 2028 V.P. Selection
Why should I care if he is a consensus top 3 pick. I can probably name 20 consensus top QBs that were complete busts and Fields will be the latest. I just hope the Jets aren't dumb enough to pick him.
wiseplayer
Pretty much a regular
My mind can change on this if he plays to the level of what he's being touted to be. His decision making is erratic when I watch him play. He's got a good arm. He can scramble. He looks to have good composure after all the mistakes he makes.
Personally I prefer Zach Wilson
