I couldn't disagree more and I am an LSU alum and fan.
What constitutes a team in your mind?
Coaching (play calling), QB, defense ... these are all big components of a team in my mind, and the factors I just listed are not even debatable as to who has the advantage.
LSU COULD be almost as good as Bama, but Crowton would rather have Lee throw the ball rather than run with his stable of 4 RBs (not including Holiday). As I said above, Saban is smart enough to realize that JPW cannot carry the offense so he uses Coffee, Ingram, and Upchurch to set up the pass.
<TABLE class=tablehead cellSpacing=1 cellPadding=3><TBODY><TR class=stathead align=middle bgColor=#a80532><TD align=left colSpan=3>
2008 Regular Season Game Log</TD><TD colSpan=8>
Passing</TD><TD colSpan=6>
Rushing</TD></TR></TR><TR class=colhead align=right><TD align=left>
DATE</TD><TD align=left>
OPP</TD><TD align=left>
RESULT </TD><TD>
CMP</TD><TD>
ATT</TD><TD>
YDS</TD><TD>
CMP%</TD><TD>
LNG</TD><TD>
TD</TD><TD>
INT</TD><TD>
RAT</TD><TD>
ATT</TD><TD>
YDS</TD><TD>
AVG</TD><TD>
LNG</TD><TD>
TD</TD></TR><TR class=oddrow align=right><TD align=left>
8/30</TD><TD align=left>
@Clemson</TD><TD align=left>
W 34-10</TD><TD>
22</TD><TD>
30</TD><TD>
180</TD><TD>
73.3</TD><TD>
24</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
145.73</TD><TD>
4</TD><TD>
19</TD><TD>
4.8</TD><TD>
15</TD><TD>
1</TD></TR><TR class=evenrow align=right><TD align=left>
9/6</TD><TD align=left>
Tulane</TD><TD align=left>
W 20-6</TD><TD>
11</TD><TD>
23</TD><TD>
73</TD><TD>
47.8</TD><TD>
15</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
74.49</TD><TD>
5</TD><TD>
-18</TD><TD>
-3.6</TD><TD>
11</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=oddrow align=right><TD align=left>
9/13</TD><TD align=left>
Western Kentucky</TD><TD align=left>
W 41-7</TD><TD>
17</TD><TD>
27</TD><TD>
215</TD><TD>
63.0</TD><TD>
36</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
146.89</TD><TD>
3</TD><TD>
20</TD><TD>
6.7</TD><TD>
20</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=evenrow align=right><TD align=left>
9/20</TD><TD align=left>
@Arkansas</TD><TD align=left>
W 49-14</TD><TD>
6</TD><TD>
14</TD><TD>
74</TD><TD>
42.9</TD><TD>
26</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
110.83</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
-10</TD><TD>
-5.0</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=oddrow align=right><TD align=left>
9/27</TD><TD align=left>
@Georgia</TD><TD align=left>
W 41-30</TD><TD>
13</TD><TD>
16</TD><TD>
205</TD><TD>
81.3</TD><TD>
31</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
209.50</TD><TD>
5</TD><TD>
13</TD><TD>
2.6</TD><TD>
7</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=evenrow align=right><TD align=left>
10/4</TD><TD align=left>
Kentucky</TD><TD align=left>
W 17-14</TD><TD>
7</TD><TD>
17</TD><TD>
106</TD><TD>
41.2</TD><TD>
24</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
81.79</TD><TD>
6</TD><TD>
-20</TD><TD>
-3.3</TD><TD>
3</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=oddrow align=right><TD align=left>
10/18</TD><TD align=left>
Mississippi</TD><TD align=left>
W 24-20</TD><TD>
16</TD><TD>
25</TD><TD>
219</TD><TD>
64.0</TD><TD>
40</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
155.98</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
-16</TD><TD>
-8.0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=evenrow align=right><TD align=left>
10/25</TD><TD align=left>
@Tennessee</TD><TD align=left>
W 29-9</TD><TD>
17</TD><TD>
24</TD><TD>
188</TD><TD>
70.8</TD><TD>
35</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
136.63</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
1.0</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
1</TD></TR><TR class=oddrow align=right><TD align=left>
11/1</TD><TD align=left>
Arkansas State</TD><TD align=left>
W 35-0</TD><TD>
15</TD><TD>
28</TD><TD>
152</TD><TD>
53.6</TD><TD>
24</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
92.03</TD><TD>
8</TD><TD>
7</TD><TD>
0.9</TD><TD>
8</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
<TABLE class=tablehead cellSpacing=1 cellPadding=3><TBODY><TR class=stathead align=middle bgColor=#2b0d57><TD align=left colSpan=3>
2008 Regular Season Game Log</TD><TD colSpan=8>
Passing</TD><TD colSpan=6>
Rushing</TD></TR></TR><TR class=colhead align=right><TD align=left>
DATE</TD><TD align=left>
OPP</TD><TD align=left>
RESULT </TD><TD>
CMP</TD><TD>
ATT</TD><TD>
YDS</TD><TD>
CMP%</TD><TD>
LNG</TD><TD>
TD</TD><TD>
INT</TD><TD>
RAT</TD><TD>
ATT</TD><TD>
YDS</TD><TD>
AVG</TD><TD>
LNG</TD><TD>
TD</TD></TR><TR class=oddrow align=right><TD align=left>
8/30</TD><TD align=left>
Appalachian State</TD><TD align=left>
W 41-13</TD><TD>
6</TD><TD>
10</TD><TD>
116</TD><TD>
60.0</TD><TD>
39</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
203.44</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0.0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=evenrow align=right><TD align=left>
9/6</TD><TD align=left>
Troy</TD><TD align=left>
Postponed </TD><TD align=middle colSpan=13>
Did Not Play or did not accumulate any stats.</TD></TR><TR class=oddrow align=right><TD align=left>
9/13</TD><TD align=left>
North Texas</TD><TD align=left>
W 41-3</TD><TD>
10</TD><TD>
18</TD><TD>
84</TD><TD>
55.6</TD><TD>
28</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
94.76</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0.0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=evenrow align=right><TD align=left>
9/20</TD><TD align=left>
@Auburn</TD><TD align=left>
W 26-21</TD><TD>
11</TD><TD>
22</TD><TD>
182</TD><TD>
50.0</TD><TD>
39</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
140.40</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0.0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=oddrow align=right><TD align=left>
9/27</TD><TD align=left>
Mississippi State</TD><TD align=left>
W 34-24</TD><TD>
18</TD><TD>
27</TD><TD>
261</TD><TD>
66.7</TD><TD>
43</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
164.91</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
-20</TD><TD>
-20.0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=evenrow align=right><TD align=left>
10/11</TD><TD align=left>
@Florida</TD><TD align=left>
L 51-21</TD><TD>
23</TD><TD>
38</TD><TD>
209</TD><TD>
60.5</TD><TD>
24</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
113.57</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
-15</TD><TD>
-7.5</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=oddrow align=right><TD align=left>
10/18</TD><TD align=left>
@South Carolina</TD><TD align=left>
W 24-17</TD><TD>
16</TD><TD>
26</TD><TD>
189</TD><TD>
61.5</TD><TD>
36</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
114.91</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
-8</TD><TD>
-8.0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=evenrow align=right><TD align=left>
10/25</TD><TD align=left>
Georgia</TD><TD align=left>
L 52-38</TD><TD>
14</TD><TD>
28</TD><TD>
287</TD><TD>
50.0</TD><TD>
66</TD><TD>
3</TD><TD>
3</TD><TD>
150.03</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
-4</TD><TD>
-4.0</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR><TR class=oddrow align=right><TD align=left>
11/1</TD><TD align=left>
Tulane</TD><TD align=left>
W 35-10</TD><TD>
8</TD><TD>
20</TD><TD>
99</TD><TD>
40.0</TD><TD>
29</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
1</TD><TD>
88.08</TD><TD>
2</TD><TD>
-33</TD><TD>
-16.5</TD><TD>
0</TD><TD>
0</TD></TR></TBODY></TABLE>
Notice how JPW attempted just 14 passes against Arkansas, a game in which Bama dominated. 16 vs UGA and 17 vs UK... all important conference games, UGA was dominated by Bama and UK was a dog fight, but Bama did not abandon their run. That is not JPW's choice, that is the work of Satan... errr, Saban!
Look, I hate to admit it more than anyone, but Bama has our ex-coach and he is better than our current coach. I admire Miles for the manner in which he conducted himself when rumors were flying about the Michigan job. I admire him for concentrating on his team and winning the SEC and the national title when all the drama was transpiring. But, there is a reason Saban received a 4yr $32mill contract, which will likely be renewed ASAP so the Tuscaloosa crazies can take comfort in knowing they have him locked up for years to come. Bama is already seeing dividends from signing Saban and his tenure is still young. Saban is the best college coach. I give Pete Carroll credit for the talent he recruits every year, but when it comes to the combo of recruiting + play calling + prepping men for the Sunday league ... NO ONE DOES IT BETTER THAN SABAN
Sorry to hijack your thread, tee, but I figure since Bama is a top play +2 you wouldn't mind some extra commentary.