I won't look at what SD did today and say that they can't do that against Indy because you're right, different teams.
That said, I don't think Dungy's game plan against SD was a bad one, I just don't think they executed until the 4th quarter.
Here's what I took from today's game that makes me want to look at Indy, Phillip Rivers sucks.
Yes, he can underthrow a guy who's 20 yards behind everybody by 10 yards, and occasionally he'll stick a tight pass exactly where it needs to be. But he's still in the learning curve. Like up to his neck in it.
If he doesn't have Gates out there as his safety valve, he's got one weapon on the outside in Chambers and you can single cover Chambers. He'll get you for four catches and 70 yards, but you can do it and not kill yourself. Were I Indy I'd bring Sanders up in run support or use whoever they can to basically shadow LT and I'd make Rivers beat me.
I have basically zero faith that Rivers can.
If SD wins that game I think it will be based on two things, the lack of Dwight Freeney for Indy and the SD defense holding Indy to under 20 points.
It's entirely possible, I just don't think they can do it.
I think Indy can get to 24 in this game and I can't see SD getting much past 20.