L
Lareux
Guest
imo he doesn't have the best brain,best work ethic,best study skills,best field vision,best prep or best execution....he has excellent skills only and the ability to continually lose big games....give me montana,bradshaw,brady,big ben,aikmen and tbh i would even take plunkett over manning
This would certainly be debatable I guess, but it seems he does have all or most of those things. I'm not sure how many other QBs in today's game would even be in the conversation in most of those areas (Brady possibly, and I'm sure there are a couple of others). I do agree that he doesn't seem to be the best playoff performer, and maybe even have the ability to lose big games...but he has won a SB and has won a bunch of playoff games as well.