This is a vintage steal for Oakland in my eyes.
As a small card collector, I follow young prospects like it's my job. Here's how I see it.
Brett Anderson may end up to be the best player the A's received in this deal. He's 2 years away from being MLB ready, but he's got great potential.
-Rediculous 5.91/1 K-BB Ratio in 120 career MILB career.
-26.1 K%, 59 GB% in A ball, 22.6 K%, 53 GB% in A+ ball
-Pretty unlucky .335 and .373 BABIP in his two stops so far.
-Solid .67 HR/9
-19 years old
-6'4" Lefty
If he can get his hit rate under 1/inning (currently 1.04), which is partially due to some bad luck then he has the potential of becoming a great lefty in the group of: CC, Rich Hill, Bedard, Kazmir
Aaron Cunningham is so underrated, it's rediculous. Everyone knows about Carlos Gonzalez, and they assume he's the centerpiece of this deal. What's the knock on Cunnigham?
They played in the same AA league this past season, let's compare #'s for this small sample size:
AC
132 PA, .288/.364/.534, .246 ISOP, 20.5 K%,
CG
508 PA, .286/.329/.476, .190 ISOP, 20.6 K%,
Pretty similar players, Gonzalez is 6 months older than Cunningham, but also has a little more experience.
Chris Carter is another 21 year old who can flat out hit bombs. Pretty big guy, 6'4 -210... He actually played with Cunningham on Kannapolis briefly in 2006. The Sally league is pretty hitter friendly, but Kannapolis is closer to pitcher friendly than a hitter's park. That makes these numbers stand out a little more. However, his K% his entire career is > 20%. That won't cut it, I don't see Carter being anything more than a low average, masher. Nothing special, but has some potential.
What D-Backs get: Dan Haren, he's certainly something special. Moving from a cozy pitcher's colliseum to Chase Field (A top 10 Hitters park) won't be as pretty of a transition as most expect. Haren has a GB% of 45 and 47% the past two seasons. Pretty similar to a Jake Peavy style (41%, 45%)
Peavys career at Chase Field: 11 GS, 59 Inn, 6.18 ERA, 1.37 WHIP
Peavy too much of a fly ball pitcher? Let's give haren the benefit of the doubt, and look at similar players with a little bit higher GB tendencies...
Carlos Zambrano (50, 48 Last 2 GB%) and Dontrelle (50, 48)
Zambrano at Chase: 4 GS, 24 Inn, 4.88 ERA, 1.58 WHIP
Willis at Chase: 2 GS, 13.2 Inn, 5.27 ERA, 1.47 WHIP
It doesn't look good for a player of Haren's pitching style. Going after another Groundball pitcher to pair up with Webb would have been more efficient, and wouldn't have unloaded half of their farm system. Don't get me wrong, I still expect Haren to put up good numbers, I'd be shocked if he comes anywhere close to 2007 Dan Haren
:tiphat:Tip of the cap to the A's on this one