L
Lareux
Guest
pretty much disagree with everything said here, so i'm gonna give the counter-opinion. i have no idea how much of a tebow fan you are, so be reasonable.
"He will turn up to practice every single day." it's his job, he's supposed to. no gold star given.
"He will work his ass off to improve himself. he doesn't believe he is limited"--working his ass off hasn't helped so far. dude can't throw, or read a playbook. hasn't learned. and him not believing he is limited is part of the problem. if he understood his limitations, a la Denard Robinson, he'd be a full back somewhere.
"He will be a leader on the field, the dressing room, and the practice field" --ehhhhh. MAYBE. maybe not though. with all that is being said about Yag players coming out of the closet, I wonder what timmy tebow would have to say about that. might turn a lot of guys off. zinger.
"He will have no off field dramas"--disagree. he's already run into drama w/speaking at uber conservative evangelical churches. He had to cancel one engagement already. it's only a matter of time before skip bayless gets caught lurking outside his bedroom window late at night. scandal!
"He won't melt under pressure"--he's got the clutch gene? maybe. i don't really believe in this so-called clutch gene. i think mental approach and footwork are a lot more important to a QB than a so called clutch gene.
"He maybe a media circus, but the attention he gets will distract the germs in the media so that the rest of the team can go about their business"--ahhh, running a million dollar interference. i get it.
"he is a playoff winning QB (not many of them out there)" --vinny vince young.
"What % of players in the NFL tick all these same boxes?" --what is the root of pie.
"considering guys like Tyrod Taylor, Chase Daniel, Matt Leinert, and some of the other bums that hold roster spots*, you can't do worse than having Tebow in your depth chart somewhere" --again. disagree. he's an ego maniac that should be playing full back. or H-back. or anything but QB. He's an extremely gifted athlete with a strong desire to win, but so are a lot of NFL players. doesn't mean they should be on a roster if they can't contribute.
Agree with this assessment.
He also isn't a playoff winning QB, unless Alan meant that he has won a playoff game. He is 1-1 in the playoffs. If it was intended that since he has won a playoff game, he is a winning playoff QB, there are lots of QBs who have won 1 playoff game (or 2 or 3 even).
I'm not even saying that he shouldn't get (or doesn't deserve) a roster spot....but it certainly wouldn't be at QB. If you want to give him a spot on your team for the leadership qualities and overall positive attitude that may translate into a winning culture, I'm all for it, but he'd be playing TE or H-Back, or even FB.
Last edited by a moderator: