RJ Esq
Prick Since 1974
ACC vs. nation
The Atlantic Coast Conference is loaded on defense but, as Caulton Tudor explains, the league may not have enough offense to field a team that can compete against the best in the country and contend for a BCS title
<!-- /components/story/story_default.comp -->Caulton Tudor, Staff Writer
Football coaches are fond of saying it's all about blocking and tackling. If they're right, the ACC should have a banner season in 2007. The league's collection of defensive linemen, linebackers, defensive backs and beefy blockers will rival, and possibly upstage, those of most other college conferences.
But if the keys to winning are passing, catching and running, '07 quickly could become an extension of the disappointing 2006 season.
For the second straight season, ACC teams will begin play with very few players of national distinction in the skill positions.
The ACC's potential for big-play production is down from last season, when Georgia Tech wide receiver Calvin Johnson was voted to The Associated Press All-America first team and finished 10th in the Heisman Trophy voting.
If there's a first-team All-America skill-position player on the 12 ACC rosters for 2007, he's well hidden.
The league's top quarterback, Boston College's Matt Ryan, is on almost none of the preseason national all-star watch lists.
Ryan's in-league competition is such that Florida State junior Drew Weatherford, No. 3 at the position in today's rankings by The News & Observer, may not keep his starting job through preseason practice. With the hiring of Jimbo Fisher as offensive coordinator, Weatherford ended spring drills listed with junior Xavier Lee as a co-No. 1.
Other than Ryan and Wake Forest sophomore Riley Skinner, ACC quarterbacks are short on experience, statistics and expectations. Duke's Thaddeus Lewis, Miami's Kyle Wright, N.C. State's Daniel Evans, Virginia's Jameel Sewell and Virginia Tech's Sean Glennon started regularly in '06, but all five were inconsistent.
Clemson, Georgia Tech, Maryland and UNC will have new starters at quarterback, but only Georgia Tech's Taylor Bennett emerged from spring drills fairly certain of having the job.
The outlook for ACC running backs is better, but that also comes with a twist. Two teams, Clemson and NCSU, have an embarrassment of riches. Other teams -- Florida State, North Carolina, Virginia and perhaps Wake -- may have more spaces than aces.
With James Davis and C.J. Spiller, Clemson has one of the nation's best tailback combinations. The Wolfpack, with Andre Brown and Toney Baker, isn't far behind. But individually, none of these four has the goods to begin the season among the country's top 10 running backs.
Three dominant runners -- Boston College's Andre Callender, Georgia Tech's Tashard Choice and Virginia Tech's Branden Ore -- could do better than the Clemson and NCSU foursome when all-star votes are tallied.
At wideout, the departure of Johnson leaves ACC receivers without a resident ruler.
Would-be successors abound. But two of the league's most talented players -- UNC's Hakeem Nicks and Maryland's Darrius Heyward-Bey, both sophomores -- could suffer from a lack of quarterback experience on their teams. Florida State junior Greg Carr, once touted as a future superstar, battled injuries and butterfingers at times last season but should benefit from Fisher's influence on the passing game.
At tight end, only N.C. State's Anthony Hill has so much as a hint of national esteem.
Without doubt, the ACC's most impressive offensive collection is its interior linemen. Three players -- tackles Barry Richardson of Clemson and Gosder Cherilus of Boston College and Wake Forest center Steve Justice -- will begin the season on most of the All-America watch lists.
Two other tackles -- Georgia Tech's Andrew Gardner and Miami's Jason Fox -- have NFL potential, as do NCSU guard Curtis Crouch and Georgia Tech center Kevin Tuminello. Virginia doesn't have an easily identifiable all-star candidate, but its offensive front will be the league's deepest and most experienced.
The ACC's top-ranked overall player is Miami safety Kenny Phillips, arguably the No. 1 defensive back in the country.
A junior, Phillips has played free and strong safety for the Hurricanes and easily could excel as a cornerback in college and possibly in the NFL. With a big season, he's a near lock for a top-10 draft position and the favorite to win the Jim Thorpe Award, which goes to the nation's top defensive back.
Behind Phillips, there's not a long drop among the league's other top defensive backs. Brandon Flowers of Virginia Tech and DeJuan Tribble of Boston College rate close behind Antoine Cason of Arizona as the best shut-down corners in the nation. Florida State's secondary should be loaded, with corner Tony Carter and safety Roger Williams. Georgia Tech safety Jamal Lewis, Virginia Tech corner Victor Harris, and Wake corner Alphonso Smith would be preseason all-star picks in some leagues.
The remainder of the ACC's defenders are almost as impressive.
With Vince Hall and Xavier Adibi, Virginia Tech's starting linebackers are probably the nation's best, even though Southern California, Penn State and Ohio State are loaded (as usual).
Miami end Calais Campbell and Florida State tackle Andre Fluellen should contend for first-team All-America honors, and Virginia end Chris Long will be in the hunt.
Among the specialists, placekickers Sam Swank of Wake and Connor Barth of UNC rate among the elite nationally, as do NCSU returner Darrell Blackman and Georgia Tech punter Durant Brooks. Overall, the ACC's personnel is not awful, but it is awfully uncertain in the touchdown-production category. If the league can't improve in that department, it won't have a legitimate national title contender for the third straight season.
The Atlantic Coast Conference is loaded on defense but, as Caulton Tudor explains, the league may not have enough offense to field a team that can compete against the best in the country and contend for a BCS title
<!-- /components/story/story_default.comp -->Caulton Tudor, Staff Writer
Football coaches are fond of saying it's all about blocking and tackling. If they're right, the ACC should have a banner season in 2007. The league's collection of defensive linemen, linebackers, defensive backs and beefy blockers will rival, and possibly upstage, those of most other college conferences.
But if the keys to winning are passing, catching and running, '07 quickly could become an extension of the disappointing 2006 season.
For the second straight season, ACC teams will begin play with very few players of national distinction in the skill positions.
The ACC's potential for big-play production is down from last season, when Georgia Tech wide receiver Calvin Johnson was voted to The Associated Press All-America first team and finished 10th in the Heisman Trophy voting.
If there's a first-team All-America skill-position player on the 12 ACC rosters for 2007, he's well hidden.
The league's top quarterback, Boston College's Matt Ryan, is on almost none of the preseason national all-star watch lists.
Ryan's in-league competition is such that Florida State junior Drew Weatherford, No. 3 at the position in today's rankings by The News & Observer, may not keep his starting job through preseason practice. With the hiring of Jimbo Fisher as offensive coordinator, Weatherford ended spring drills listed with junior Xavier Lee as a co-No. 1.
Other than Ryan and Wake Forest sophomore Riley Skinner, ACC quarterbacks are short on experience, statistics and expectations. Duke's Thaddeus Lewis, Miami's Kyle Wright, N.C. State's Daniel Evans, Virginia's Jameel Sewell and Virginia Tech's Sean Glennon started regularly in '06, but all five were inconsistent.
Clemson, Georgia Tech, Maryland and UNC will have new starters at quarterback, but only Georgia Tech's Taylor Bennett emerged from spring drills fairly certain of having the job.
The outlook for ACC running backs is better, but that also comes with a twist. Two teams, Clemson and NCSU, have an embarrassment of riches. Other teams -- Florida State, North Carolina, Virginia and perhaps Wake -- may have more spaces than aces.
With James Davis and C.J. Spiller, Clemson has one of the nation's best tailback combinations. The Wolfpack, with Andre Brown and Toney Baker, isn't far behind. But individually, none of these four has the goods to begin the season among the country's top 10 running backs.
Three dominant runners -- Boston College's Andre Callender, Georgia Tech's Tashard Choice and Virginia Tech's Branden Ore -- could do better than the Clemson and NCSU foursome when all-star votes are tallied.
At wideout, the departure of Johnson leaves ACC receivers without a resident ruler.
Would-be successors abound. But two of the league's most talented players -- UNC's Hakeem Nicks and Maryland's Darrius Heyward-Bey, both sophomores -- could suffer from a lack of quarterback experience on their teams. Florida State junior Greg Carr, once touted as a future superstar, battled injuries and butterfingers at times last season but should benefit from Fisher's influence on the passing game.
At tight end, only N.C. State's Anthony Hill has so much as a hint of national esteem.
Without doubt, the ACC's most impressive offensive collection is its interior linemen. Three players -- tackles Barry Richardson of Clemson and Gosder Cherilus of Boston College and Wake Forest center Steve Justice -- will begin the season on most of the All-America watch lists.
Two other tackles -- Georgia Tech's Andrew Gardner and Miami's Jason Fox -- have NFL potential, as do NCSU guard Curtis Crouch and Georgia Tech center Kevin Tuminello. Virginia doesn't have an easily identifiable all-star candidate, but its offensive front will be the league's deepest and most experienced.
The ACC's top-ranked overall player is Miami safety Kenny Phillips, arguably the No. 1 defensive back in the country.
A junior, Phillips has played free and strong safety for the Hurricanes and easily could excel as a cornerback in college and possibly in the NFL. With a big season, he's a near lock for a top-10 draft position and the favorite to win the Jim Thorpe Award, which goes to the nation's top defensive back.
Behind Phillips, there's not a long drop among the league's other top defensive backs. Brandon Flowers of Virginia Tech and DeJuan Tribble of Boston College rate close behind Antoine Cason of Arizona as the best shut-down corners in the nation. Florida State's secondary should be loaded, with corner Tony Carter and safety Roger Williams. Georgia Tech safety Jamal Lewis, Virginia Tech corner Victor Harris, and Wake corner Alphonso Smith would be preseason all-star picks in some leagues.
The remainder of the ACC's defenders are almost as impressive.
With Vince Hall and Xavier Adibi, Virginia Tech's starting linebackers are probably the nation's best, even though Southern California, Penn State and Ohio State are loaded (as usual).
Miami end Calais Campbell and Florida State tackle Andre Fluellen should contend for first-team All-America honors, and Virginia end Chris Long will be in the hunt.
Among the specialists, placekickers Sam Swank of Wake and Connor Barth of UNC rate among the elite nationally, as do NCSU returner Darrell Blackman and Georgia Tech punter Durant Brooks. Overall, the ACC's personnel is not awful, but it is awfully uncertain in the touchdown-production category. If the league can't improve in that department, it won't have a legitimate national title contender for the third straight season.