OK, I'm going to play a bit of a skeptic regarding Oakmont's fearsome reputation holding form this week. Let me throw some thoughts out here.
A) Oakmont is fully invested in its inland links personality. The few trees that line the course perimeters are completely a non-factor (I think they were last time as well). This course will rely on three things for defense: 1) High, thick rough, 2) Slick undulating greens, 3) Acres of bunkers. There are also drainage ditches running alongside many of the holes south of the Turnpike, but you'll need to be way of course to land in most of them. Bunkers as we know are not much of a problem for pros. They'll take that over rough any day. The rough needs wind to play havoc on shots, and the greens need to be firm to make them their toughest. Which bring us to:
B) Weather - After a cold wet May, the area got about 2 inches of rain this weekend. There are forecasts for more rain tonight. Then it'll be dry Tuesday-Friday but only in the 70s Tue/Wed then mid-80s Thu-Sun with thunderstorm chances Sat/Sun. A couple of days of dry weather will not be enough to make these greens firm. The rough will be lush, but do these guys really care? Because:
C) Golf has been totally converted to a bomb & gouge style of play. Scottie was lamenting this fact not long ago. With portable launch monitors these guys are all focused on distance. One more weather note: there is NO wind in the forecast for this week. Without trees or wind it will be bombs away and gouge out a wedge to a green with some give in it. Everyone is going to have the same strategy....it'll be like how every college team now employs the same spread offense. This course is not long enough to stop it:
Hole 1 - 488 yards, but downhill, with minimal bunkers. Fly it 320 and at worst it's a 9 iron, many will be hitting wedge. Somehow this was the hardest hole last time.
Hole 2 - 346 yards. There's a decent size landing area for drivers that leaves are little pitch. A+ birdie hole.
Hole 3 - 462 yards. Good uphill par 4 with a hogsback green and narrowing fairway in the landing area. Ranked #7 last time, I'm think top 4 this time.
Hole 4 - 611 yards. Downhill par 5 is another good birdie opportunity with a huge green to receive fairway woods.
Hole 5 - 408 yards. Blindish tee shot but easy enough to have a wedge in your hands for the approach. Another good early birdie opportunity.
Hole 6 - 200 yards. Not a terribly hard hole, for pros it's probably going to be a 6-7 iron. Green has three areas....have to land in the right one. A mid-level birdie op. So, the first six holes you have a good chance of being 2 or 3 under. Then hang on to finish the front nine.
Hole 7 - 485 yards. Legit toughie here with length and a tiered green. Was #5 hardest last time, will be about that again.
Hole 8 - 289 yards. Pretty large green and better for hooks than fades. Hit it, two putt and whistle across the Turnpike.
Hole 9 - 472 yards. Plays as a par 5 for members, so no surprise it was #2 ranked last time. All uphill, with a green connected to the practice green. You could see some 30 yard putts. After 4 decent birdie chances the first 6 holes, hanging on to whatever you may have gained on the last 3 will a key.
Hole 10 - 461 yards. Kind of similar to #1, downhill, no fairway bunkers. The ditches are not far off the fairway on the right. #4 rank last time. Get past this and you're done with four of the five toughest holes already.
Hole 11 - 400 yards - One of the weak links at Oakmont. Wedges into a green surrounded by 3 sides on bunkers. Ranked 14th last time. Good birdie opp.
Hole 12 - 632 yards - They shortened this hole since 2016 but have kept the serpentine fairway. Another front to back green, I think this plays much softer than the #10 ranking it had last time.
Hole 13 - 182 yards - The shortest par 3 played at 2.99 average last time.
Hole 14 - 379 yards - Tons of bunkers but it plays pretty easy. 3.99 average last time. So like the front, the back offers decent birdie chances through many of the first 5 holes.
Hole 15 - 507 yards - Fairways slopes left to right favoring draw hitters. Green is huge, also slopes hard left to right. The last of the 5 toughest last time out.
Hole 16 - 236 yards - Solid, tough par 3. Pins on the left side are gettable, on the right will not be. Ranked #9 last time.
Hole 17 - 312 yards - 129 birdies were made here last time, and the winner had none of them. This is one of the holes where the green firmness (or softness) makes a big difference. Dechambeau drove it in 50 degree temps last weekend.
Hole 18 - 502 yard - Good solid hole, ranked #6 last time. I'm surprised it doesn't play tougher than #1, but that could because everyone feels pressure on #1, but only a select few will feel it on #18.
As far as a winning score, I look at this course and see strong birdie chances on 2, 4, 5, 6, 11, 12, 13, 14 and 17. #1 and #10 can be had by the bigger hitters. You're hanging on at 3, 7, 8, 9, 15, 16 and 18. I go back to 2016 and see -4 won it, but I also see that Lowery finished the 3rd round at -7. I think -8 is doable this week. Softer conditions, light wind, longer hitters, the bomb and gouge mentality in full bloom. I don't think it plays quite as hard as many hope it will.