Rank Your Top Current Head Coaches

[Sammy Meatballs]

There is a site called headcoachranking.com. They use the following criteria, assign an HCR score, and then adjust the rankings weekly...1. Play calling 2. Personnel utilization 3. Game planning 4. In-game adjustments and 5. Clock management. It looks as if they're missing a few items that have been mentioned such as 4th down punt/go for it, when to go for 2, and challenges, but it seems to be the most comprehensive rankings out there (that I've found thus far at least).

Here is their current top 10:
1. Payton 8.2
2. Reid 8.0
3. McVay 7.9
4. Nagy 7.8
T5 Belichick 7.7
T5 Harbaugh 7.7
7. Williams 7.5
T8 Lynn 7.4
T8 Carroll 7.4
10. Reich 7.2

I think they're on to something. That's a pretty damn good list.

The bottom 5 are Wilks, Jon Gruden, Marrone, McDermott, and Shurmur

Excellent post to show the utter and complete uselessness of stats---

The criteria they used is completely NON CREDIBLE--- How is Andy Reid #2??? We know Andy is nowhere near the top 5 in the NFL in coaching--

Its very funny to see REID so high-- He has the stats but in terms of tangible coaching he sucks-- ALways has always will- He cant challenge a call- loses track of time in late game situations etc-

 

[DBURGH]

Like I said Tomlin sucks. Wtf. No f-ing clue.