Marlins early results against lhp have been much improved over last season. They had one of if not the worst k rate against lhp, they were the absolute worst in the league on base percentage team against lhp. They were a stacked right handed hitting lineup so I found it odd but it didn’t stop me from playing all kinds of lhp k props against them and cashing a bunch! I still don’t know why that was? The strikeouts more explainable than the worst obp in the league. It could be lhp throw lot of junk below the zone and fish are not a patient squad, it could be their right handed hitters simply don’t pick ball up as well as many out of lefties hands? It’s not like they were a great obp team vs rhp either.
I looked at a recent start by Phillies lhp Matt strahm and fish performed a lot like they did against lhp last year! At 31 Stahm has been mostly a reliever with some spot starts throughout his career, clearly not a guy with special stuff, he has some seasons with fantastic k:bb ratio’s and some where the k’s way down, he never walks many. His swinging strike rate hasn’t been above 10% for years, all these things should drop off when he starts as most relievers do when taking on a starting role. he pretty much stifled the fish for 5 innings with 6:1 k:bb and no runs allowed.
I bring all that up cause tonight fish facing another lhp who stuff is a long ways from special anymore. Even with the massive drop off madbum is not gonna be a 10era gas can. Imo he is a 4.50ish era kinda guy, that gets a bump from having to pitch in a tough park for pitchers to where he been around 4.80 since joining zona. I know era is outdated but end of day how many runs you allow is pretty important to whether your team wins! It’s not really predictive going forward is fair to say but his fip/xfip has fell right in line with his era pitching for snakes and they all been incredibly close the last couple years. After facing a good lad lineup twice this game screams positive regression for madbum. He had to try and pitch around dodgers lineup cause his stuff not getting elite hitters out in the zone, as a result he has walked a ton of guys in those 2 starts. He not gonna go from a 2-3 walk per 9 guy his whole career into a 10 walks per 9 guy! He had a 6.1 inning 2 runs allowed start vs fish last year, for some reason he was slated to pitch against them b2b times fairly early last season, something happened in the start in Miami and he left game after a inning, then he came back the prior week and had the great effort vs marlins in Arizona. Imo it stands to reason he should have a better time in the Miami park.
This seems like a good spot for him to pitch well especially with the price attached. All a sudden the fish are a team laying -160 with Rogers starting who one the most inconsistent no control having pitchers around, I don’t think he knows where ball going when he throws it! Rogers talented, if this was a “who has better stuff” contest he would beat madbum every time, unfortunately for him he facing a scrappy snakes lineup who doesn’t do a lot of striking out so he will have to put pitches in the k zone. Whether he can do that is anyones guess on a given night, if he does that they are often pitches that catch way more of the plate than a good pitcher wants to. +140 a really good price to play snakes who I think are pretty close to the fish overall. What separates these teams to that price? I’m sure I don’t get it, they have played the dodgers 8x and have a 5-3 record but they only have a 41% chance to beat the marlins with one their more inconsistent starting pitchers on the bump? I don’t think so, I think snakes have way closer to a 447-48% chance of winning this game, if not 50%!