I have always felt that there is no "value" in a losing bet. Like you said, either A wins or B wins, and the value was with the winner, regardless of how it played out. I do understand the play X amount of times to win, because some gamblers bet based on numbers, they feel a game of x will win 60% of the time and they are getting a good price (same as pot odds in poker).
I see value in -300 plays, where as others think they would never risk that because you have to win 3 out 4 times. I see it as being able to bank a unit. I'd rather bet -300 for a slightly different line than the masses and not have to worry about winning by 2 runs, just stay within 2 runs. You run into problems with bad MM, but if you can space out your losses, you can make money on -300 plays, you just have to be selective on your plays and learn from your mistakes.
I don't know how you track the crucial points, though I am guessing from looking at play by plays, but you seem to look for an opportunity missed, that you think will be made the next day because a team is getting closer to winning. For example, Padres when they got Headley back, were swinging the bats in MIL Game 2, but bounced into a couple DP's to kill rallies, yet you still felt they were heading right direction and had confidence they would breakthrough next day, which they did while getting a great pitching performance from Volquez.
I think its wise to profile teams, will be something I will be working on. I just want you to know that I appreciate your breakdowns and hope you continue to do them and kill the books. I don't always agree with you, but lately you have been way more right than wrong.
I am tracking how teams do as big favorites and looking for edges there. This season, there certainly are days that are favorite and days that are dogs, though the last week has been inconsistent. I keep track of it on weekly basis, not just basing on it the whole number so I can see where its headed.
Your comment about stats are a reflection of performance...is telling me you have a Power Ranking in your head, that tells you that even though Team A is struggling and has bad stats, its because of their competition, but when they step down in class, they will be perceived to be weak, but really be strong. Something along those lines.
Thanks for the responses. BOL!