Either QB gets Bearcats' OK
Offense confident with either Collaros or Anderson in role
By Bill Koch •
bkoch@enquirer.com • October 2, 2008
Zach Collaros has been compared to former QB Ben Mauk.
Chazz Anderson has impressed teammates with his strong arm.
You'd never know from talking to the other players on the University of Cincinnati's offensive unit that the Bearcats face a precarious situation Friday, having to play at Marshall with two untested redshirt freshman quarterbacks.
Either they have the utmost confidence in Zach Collaros and Chazz Anderson, or they're doing a remarkably convincing job of parroting the company line.
"These guys were awesome in high school," running back John Goebel said. "They're here for a reason. They'll do their job."
Said wide receiver Mardy Gilyard: "It doesn't matter who's under the center. We trust all the guys that go under there. Both of those guys are highly capable of doing the job."
UC head coach Brian Kelly wasn't surprised to hear that his players seem so unfazed after having lost two quarterbacks - first Dustin Grutza and then Tony Pike - to injury. They've seen a lot of both Collaros and Anderson in practice, first during the spring and then during the preseason.
Goebel worked extensively with Collaros and Anderson last year when all three of them were redshirted, so he saw first-hand what each can do.
"When my parents would ask me who's good, I could never choose," Goebel said. "I didn't know who I liked better, Zach or Chazz. On the scout team last year they would throw passes that I didn't know were possible. They'd be running back to the right and throw it back to the left on a dime.
"Zach is such a good scrambler. He kind of reminds me a little bit of (former UC quarterback) Ben Mauk in that he has the escapability and can still throw it downfield really far. He's got a great arm. Chazz, he's so smart. He's always in the playbook and Chazz can do a lot with his arm, too."
Goebel isn't the only player to have recognized similarities between Mauk, last year's starter, and Collaros. Mauk himself made the same comparison last year, and Gilyard also said he sees shades of Mauk in the raw freshman.
"I hate to put that tag on him like that, but I love him when he rolls out of the pocket," Gilyard said. "It's just so beautiful when the ball comes out of his hands when he rolls out. It's like pin-point accuracy with tight spirals. Chazz, he has a strong cannon for an arm. He likes to drop back and trust the pocket."
Kelly has not tipped his hand about which quarterback will start and has played along with questions from reporters about the competition between Collaros and Anderson, encouraging the notion that he doesn't know whom to choose, that he won't decide until just before the game Friday night, and that he probably will play both of them.
"My sense right now is that I want Marshall to prepare for multiple quarterbacks," he said Monday, "and I think each one of them brings something different to the table."
Still, neither has any meaningful experience in a game. Collaros threw four passes in relief of Pike at Akron last Saturday, and Anderson has yet to play in a college game.
No matter how good they might have looked in practice, no matter how impressively they might have run the scout team last year, it's not the same as playing on the road in a hostile environment when it really counts.
Sure, it's possible that whoever starts will play well and the offense won't skip a beat, but that won't happen without a lot of help from the rest of the offense.
Right guard Trevor Canfield says the offensive line is up to the task.
"We haven't given up a sack in two games," Canfield said. "No offense to Coach Kelly, but you could put him back there and we'd be all right. We've got confidence in Zach, Chazz, Pike, Demetrius (Jones), Grutza.
Our offensive line is so strong that it really doesn't matter."
As for the bolded comment, Canfield's wrong. The OL is average.