Would you Trade (NFL)

[Fondybadger]

Would you give up Steven Jackson, Marvin Harrison and Rex Grossman for Adrian Peterson, Santana Moss, and VY?

 

[mogo]

in a heartbeat.

 

[Gorgolon Lives]

I wouldnt.

 

[deuce's wild]

Tough one but I would go for it, Jackson is going to struggle all year with the injuries STL has and now his own injury. Rex is done in Chicago so your upgrading with VY for sure, Peterson is running really well and should hold up over the course of the season with Minny's run game. THe biggest blow your losing is Harrison but you are getting Moss so you will get production just not as much with Harrison each week.

 

[Tide High]

tough one. i'd like to know more about SJax's injury if possible. but wouldnt everyone...

 

[mogo]

VY > Rex (easy one considering rex is on the bench now)

normally i would say SJ > AP but with SJ hurt and AP running like he has, i have to flip it.

AP > SJ (stl offensive problems will likely continue and if leonard runs well this weekend i doubt SJ will be rushed back to 25+ carries a game. AP has gotten around 20 carries a game and has certainly made the most of them. he will probably be minn. starting even when taylor comes back)

MH > SM

here is the small dilemma. nobody in their right mind wold take SM over MH. MH is obviously a top 5 WR will SM is probably only a top 15 WR. however SM is a reliable WR, and depending on how deep u are at WR it might not be a huge drop off between MH and SM. SM will put up decent numbers just about every week, while sometimes MH gets lost in the colts offense and only gets about 50 rec yds.


do u want to lose a proven #1 WR and only get a servicable #1?

do u want to get a starting, and on the rise, QB & RB vs. one on the decline, on the bench, or hurt?

honestly i think this is an easy trade...... seems there are differing opinions though...

 

[t-dot]

I keep Jackson. He's just off to a bad start. Jackson can carry your team into the play-offs. You cant say that for anyone you would get in return.

Make the trade if your behind. If your team is solid and is hovering near the middle of the pack; keep him.

 

[Tide High]

i also dont like APs upcoming schedule. check it. btw i'm trying to sell high on AP right now in one of my leagues... what is to come for AP is brutal.

last 3 - he went off...
Atl
Detroit
KC

next few... uggglee
GB
BYE
CHI
DAL
PHILLY
SD
GB
OAK


then he gets a couple of decent match ups... but the 1st week of the playoffs(for a 3 week system - something everyone should consider in every trade) is vs the Bears...

 

[ATLHawksBandwagon]

Also, Chester Taylor is back this week ... I'm pretty sure this is going to be the highest his value will be all season.

 

[Tide High]

should i get roy williams for AP? i know i can. but wonder if im giving up too much since the guy desperately needs RBs. (he has deuce, and betts)

 

[Gorgolon Lives]

It's pretty hard to trade the #2 overall pick AND an elite WR.

 

[Tide High]

exactly. i don't think i could live with myself. it is only week 3

 

[Tide High]

er 4

 

[signalcaller]

I wouldnt do it.

 

[Smokedawg]

not a chance - you should be able to get way more than peterson and santana moss for jackson and harrison, even given jacksons status

 

[Fondybadger]

First it's not my team - my roommate drafted it and it's a $250 buy in, $10 per transaction league. He's 0-3...

His starting roster, seeing he didn't make the trade this week is...

Brian Griese
Kevin Jones
Brandon Jackson
Marvin Harrison
Wes Welker
Jeff Wilkens
Indy Defense

Talk about being scared of that lineup (laugh)... Hard having the #2, 31st, 34th picks then nothing again til 63 & 66... Seeing those picks where Stephen Jackson, Drew Brees, Marvin Harrison he's in trouble.

 

[Tide High]

wow, he is in trouble, but so are a lot of other lineups, I assume.

 

[Tide High]

again about AP. everything i've read lately has been about how they don't want to overworkhim. he's going to be sharing a ton of time with taylor, and now theyve even named taylor the starter. i couldnt get anyone to bite on him for anything good in my league.