Who would you keep? (Part 2)

[TheLaw4]

Very similar situation as ljc, but didn't want to hijack his thread. Just like his league, you lose the round pick from where you got them last year.

Peyton Manning (7th round) or
Colin Kaepernick (15th round)

I was all set on keeping Kaep as there could be value there for years (pick moves up one round each subsequent year kept), but I'm starting to doubt myself and keepers are due tonight.

 

[mcdrewcarey187]

Kaep.

 

[ljc_267]

This year I go Manning.

If you are looking long term it's Kaepernick by a mile.

 

[reNew Orleans]

is there a max on how long you can keep a guy?

I go Kaep

 

[orangemonk]

Peyton is still considerably better than kaepernick, who is also working with a small sample size. I keep Peyton. You'll have guys next year who you'll have a similar debate about. Make your team a lot better this year

 

[TheLaw4]

No there is no max on years. It just keeps going up one round every year.

Thanks for the input but it might be solving itself. Currently in last minute negotiations on a trade.

 

[KowboyKarl]

Peyton is still considerably better than kaepernick, who is also working with a small sample size. I keep Peyton. You'll have guys next year who you'll have a similar debate about. Make your team a lot better this year

I agree with this and would go this route. You can always find another QB when Peyton hangs it up.

 

[Tide High]

Manning.

 

[TheLaw4]

Ended up with Kaepernick.

Traded Manning and my 11th round pick for a 3rd and a 8th round pick. Feel satisfied enough with the outcome.

Thanks again for the thoughts

 

[Jumpsinn]

ekkk I was just about to write Manning no questions, but Good Luck. Hope it turns out for ya!

 

[IvyinBarondise]

It again depends on the size of your league...

10 team? Peyton
12 team? Peyton
14 team? close
16 team? Might go with Kap

the shorter the field, the more the elite player is valued

 

[IvyinBarondise]

btw...I'm of the win now mindset lol

 

[IvyinBarondise]

peyton will be top three this season...potential for tops in the league

 

[Tide High]

peyton will be top three this season...potential for tops in the league

i keep thinking the same thing. 4500 yards, 40+ TDs has to be coming. see my thread if you don't mind

 

[TheLaw4]

Told you guys I should've kept Manning...

 

[KowboyKarl]

I agree with this and would go this route. You can always find another QB when Peyton hangs it up.

:shake:

 

[IvyinBarondise]

peyton will be top three this season...potential for tops in the league

while we're patting ourselves on the back

 

[Tide High]

Fuck I kept ray over peyton 1st vs 5th.

 

[IvyinBarondise]

this is Peyton's year

 

[Tide High]

Pierre thomas
roy helu
kenny ststills

ughhhhh