BA
Assuming BYU doesn't beat TT, will ND or Miami get the last spot in the playoffs? If ND and Miami are sitting side by side, how can the committee put ND in over a team that beat them? If Georgia beats Bama, can/should ND and Miami pass them and get in?
That's an easy one....
It's a seriously flawed system - based on popularity, and money - drowning in bias and and good ol boy politics.
>> so FAIRNESS is not really part of the equation.
The committee actually does a decent job, given an impossible task. Start with power rankings > consider 'good wins/losses'......'bad wins/ losses' > SOS. Ridiculous.
Why not just play it off - WINNER ADVANCES, like every other team sport on earth? They probably like all the attention this BS get's each year. Like you say - how TF can a head to head, not matter? But in this type of selection process, if you put major emphasis on head to head - you'll go down a rabbit hole that ends up in China somewhere. If they don't fix it, top teams (like Sark said) will just schedule weaker teams in the non-conference.
Here's a PR composite .....using SP+, Vegas, Sagarin, and a few more
* considering su/ats/sos as well...
1. OSU
2. Indy
3. ND
4. Ducks
5. TT
6. Ga
7. Ala
8. A&M
9. Miami
10. Ole Miss
11. OU 10-2 su / 6-5 ats / SOS #10
12. Vandy 10-2 su / 9-2 ats / SOS #21
THEN a decent drop off (IMO) :
13. Utes 10-2 / #58 SOS / several weak efforts
14. Texas 9-3 / #13 SOS / about 4 weak to terrible efforts
15. USC 9-3 / #33 SOS / fine year, not play-off worthy
16. BYU 11-1 / #44 SOS / beat TT and you're in - great year, but not a top 10 type team
* Iowa - Tenn - Mizzou - Washington
$$ If you start talking about who 'deserves' what - only these teams dominated most every week, and (arguably) DESERVE a spot:
(3) Indiana - TTech - Ohio State ....then maybe Oregon, maybe Georgia. That's really about it. Irish, Texas, Miami, BAMA? have arguments, but too many moments of "wtf is going on here?" Take your nice bowl / stfu - try again next year. Don't get pushed around by UTEP whydontcha...
SOLUTION:
Have 2 divisions :
* FBS l - P4
* FBS ll - G4-5
>> each has 4 conferences, with 2 divisions each = auto 8 team play-off
So this year we might have:
FBS l champ > Ohio State
FBS ll champ > JMU
Winner advances - loser goes home, and to a great bowl. Maybe reseed each division every 5 years or so?