May 17 Wed 2023
| 01:10 PM | ||||
| 967 | Pittsburgh PiratesR. Hill -L | +1½ -160 | +140 | O 8 +100 |
| 968 | Detroit TigersE. Rodriguez -L+1 Markets | -1½ +140 | -152 | U 8 -120 |
| 03:10 PM | ||||
| 951 | Cincinnati RedsG. Ashcraft -R | +1½ -170 | +110 | O 11 -115 |
| 952 | Colorado RockiesA. Gomber -L+1 Markets | -1½ +150 | -120 | U 11 -105 |
| 03:10 PM | ||||
| 969 | Minnesota TwinsS. Gray -R | +1½ -155 | +136 | O 8½ -110 |
| 970 | Los Angeles DodgersD. May -R+1 Markets | -1½ +135 | -147 | U 8½ -110 |
| 03:37 PM | ||||
| 971 | Arizona DiamondbacksR. Nelson -R | -1½ +105 | -151 | O 9½ +100 |
| 972 | Oakland AthleticsL. Medina -R+1 Markets | +1½ -125 | +139 | U 9½ -120 |
| 06:35 PM | ||||
| 959 | Los Angeles AngelsG. Canning -R | +1½ -160 | +126 | O 9½ -106 |
| 960 | Baltimore OriolesK. Bradish -R+1 Markets | -1½ +140 | -136 | U 9½ -114 |
| 06:40 PM | ||||
| 955 | Washington NationalsM. Gore -L | +1½ -180 | +120 | O 7½ -115 |
| 956 | Miami MarlinsE. Cabrera -R+1 Markets | -1½ +160 | -130 | U 7½ -105 |
| 07:07 PM | ||||
| 961 | New York YankeesG. Cole -R | -1½ +145 | -112 | O 8½ +105 |
| 962 | Toronto Blue JaysC. Bassitt -R+1 Markets | +1½ -165 | +102 | U 8½ -125 |
| 07:10 PM | ||||
| 963 | Seattle MarinersM. Gonzales -L | +1½ -167 | +112 | O 10 -110 |
| 964 | Boston Red SoxB. Bello -R+1 Markets | -1½ +147 | -122 | U 10 -110 |
| 07:45 PM | ||||
| 957 | Milwaukee BrewersC. Burnes -R | -1½ +130 | -120 | O 8½ -107 |
| 958 | St. Louis CardinalsA. Wainwright -R+1 Markets | +1½ -150 | +110 | U 8½ -113 |
| 08:05 PM | ||||
| 977 | Atlanta BravesS. Strider -R | -1½ +110 | -147 | O 7½ -105 |
| 978 | Texas RangersN. Eovaldi -R+1 Markets | +1½ -130 | +136 | U 7½ -115 |
| 08:10 PM | ||||
| 965 | Cleveland GuardiansP. Battenfield -R | +100 | O 9 -105 | |
| 966 | Chicago White SoxM. Clevinger -R+1 Markets | -110 | U 9 -115 |
| 08:10 PM | ||||
| 979 | Chicago CubsD. Smyly -L | +1½ -150 | +135 | O 9 +102 |
| 980 | Houston AstrosJ. France -R+1 Markets | -1½ +130 | -146 | U 9 -122 |