Wow, 1-7 -17 Stars. I would love to hear how he is spinning this week to his sheep.
Well here it is. It's long as hell and full of whining:
College Football Recap - 2007
I know you're all very disappointed with what happened this week and with the season overall, as this will turn out to be my worst College football season in my 21 years as a professional handicapper - and only my 5th unprofitable season (only the 3rd under 50%). Those of you that are sophisticated sports bettors know that there is variance in sports betting and that my 3 seasons at 64% prior to this year (and my 59% college record over the previous 9 years and 57% over 20 years) didn't guarantee a winning season. I can assure you that I didn't suddenly forget how to handicap or that I am not working as hard because I'm working more hours than I ever have. The difference between this year and other seasons is negative variance and that variance has come in the form of numerous games in which I clearly had the right side and lost anyway due to a large number of turnovers, missed extra points and other random occurrences. Those sort of losses happen every year (although not as often as this year), but what has made this year different is that I haven't had my share of lucky wins on games in which I was on the wrong side. In fact, I have not had one lucky win all season and I challenge any of you to find a game I was lucky to win in which I obviously had the wrong side. I have won a few games that could have gone either way, but I have a decidedly losing record on toss-up games this season.
I though perhaps it just selective memory that I was getting screwed a lot this year on games I should have won and maybe I was just forgetting some fortunate wins. I decided to go over every box score and play by play on all my Best Bets this season to find out if I had conveniently forgotten about a few lucky wins.
Below is a recap of every College Best Bet this season and I put each game into one of three categories. A game in which my team should have covered based on yards per play and other predictable events was considered being on the right side. A game in which I deserved to lose based on yardage is considered being on the wrong side and games that really could have gone either way based on the yardage and a reasonable turnover differential was considered a toss up game. You'll see me refer to turnover margin a lot in this recap because turnovers are 75% random in college football and often determine which team covers the spread. Anything beyond a -1 or +1 in turnover margin in a game is random as even favorites of 28 points or more would not be forecasted to be +2 in turnover margin very often.
You can go through each game below and you'll see that my assessment of each game is unbiased and based on what the projected margin would be based on yards per play and a reasonable turnover margin between -1 and +1. If you don't know already, yards per play is a much stronger indicator of the better team than total yards.
The results of my study are pretty much what I thought they were.
I have had 29 games in which I was on the right side and I'm 23-5-1 on those games, which is a win percentage that is about normal for being on the right side of a game.
I have had 22 games in which I was obviously on the wrong side and I have lost them all (where are my lucky wins???).
I have had 15 games that I consider toss up games based on the stats and my record on those toss up games, which should be 50%, is just 5-10.
So, I have been on the right side 7 more times than I've been on the wrong side and
my Best Bet record would be 36-29-1 if I won the 29 games in which I was on the right side, lost the 22 games in which I was on the wrong side, and went 7-7-1 on the 15 toss-up games. Because I've had 5 unlucky losses, one unlucky push, zero lucky wins and have a record of just 5-10 on the toss-up games my record is 28-37-1 instead of 36-29-1.
So, my analysis has not been nearly as bad as my record indicates. I usually wait until the off-season to do this analysis and I've certainly had years when my record was better than it should be (I was 74% on a Star Basis in 2005 and should have been 66%) and the last time there was significant negative variance was in 2003 when I was 46-55-2 on my College Best Bets when I graded out at 54% that year. People doubted me after that bad 2003 season and then I went 64% on my College Best Bets over the next 3 seasons combined, so one bad year that is the result of negative variance and not bad analysis does not mean that I am suddenly a bad handicapper.
Here is the list of this year's College Best Bets. I'm sure you'll find that I was extremely fair in my assessment of each game.
Week 1
No Best Bets
Week 2
***Cincinnati (+3 ½) 31 Oregon State 3
Cincinnati was +5 in turnovers and had a blocked punt for a TD, but that's not a lucky win because they didn't need the turnovers to cover. The Bearcats averaged 4.8 yards per play and allowed 4.1 yppl and were the underdog. Right Side - Winner.
**Navy (+16 ½) 24 Rutgers 41
This game could have gone either way and I end up losing by ½ a point. Navy was -2 in turnovers as quarterback Kaipo-Noa Kaheaku-Enhada threw 3 in this one game and threw just 1 interception TOTAL in his other 9 games. I won't call that an unlucky win, but that is a toss-up game that I barely lost. Toss up - Loser.
**Oregon (+8) 39 Michigan 7
Right Side - Winner.
2-Stars South Carolina (+4) 16 Georgia 12
South Carolina was +1 in turnover margin, but the Gamecocks out played Georgia from the line of scrimmage 4.8 yppl to 4.5 yppl. I would have called this a toss-up game if it was within 7 points of the line, but the underdog covered by 8 points and out-played the favorite. Ride Side - Winner.
**North Carolina (+6) 31 East Carolina 34
This game was originally a Strong Opinion, but the line moved to +6 on Saturday morning making it a 2-Star and I sent out an email a couple hours before the game alerting everyone that it was officially a play. North Carolina out played ECU 6.8 yppl to 6.4 yppl and covered despite being -2 in turnovers - although a punt return TD helped balance out those turnovers. This game was tight the entire way and I was getting 6 points. ECU won on a field goal on the last play of the game. Borderline toss-up game but having a 6 point dog out-gain the favorite indicates I had the right side in this one. Right side - winner.
**Tulane (+6 ½) 17 Miss State 38
Tulane was dominated. Wrong side - loser.
**Virginia Tech (+12 ½) 7 LSU 41
Virginia Tech's defense was great before this game and great after this game but were horrible during this game. Wrong Side - Loser.
Week 3
***Miami-Ohio (+8 ½) 10 Cincinnati 47
Wrong side - Loser.
***Kansas (-23) 45 Toledo 13
Kansas dominated 557 yards at 6.6 yppl to 251 yards at 4.1 yppl. Right side - Winner.
**Kentucky (+6 ½) 40 Louisville 34
Funny to think that Kentucky was a 6 ½ point home dog to a Louisville team with a horrible defense. Kentucky was actually out-played from the line of scrimmage 460 yards at 5.8 yppl while Louisville had 467 yards at 6.7 and Kentucky's +2 in turnovers was off-set by a Louisville kickoff return TD. Kentucky never trailed by more than 2 points but I'll call this one a toss-up. Toss up - Winner.
Week 4
**Navy (-11 ½) 46 Duke 43
Wrong side - loser.
***Arizona (+15) 27 California 45
Arizona fell behind 3-28 on a few turnovers, including a fumble that was scooped up and run in for a Cal TD. Arizona came back to have the number covered before Cal scored midway through the 4th quarter. Arizona was in scoring territory a couple of times after that and passed up on a short field goal attempt with 2 ½ minutes left that would have resulted in a spread push. Arizona was -2 in turnover margin and failed to cover by only 3 points. This game could have gone either way. Toss up - loser.
***LSU (-16 ½) 28 S Carolina 16
LSU was up 28-7 midway through the 4th quarter and out played the Gamecocks 5.5 yppl to 3.8 yppl but LSU was +2 in turnovers. South Carolina scored the covering TD with 1:41 left with the Tigers in a prevent defense. This game could have gone either way based on the yppl differential. Toss up - Loser.
Week 5
***Toledo (+1 ½) 28 W. Michigan 42
Wrong side - Loser.
**Kent State (-2 ½) 33 Ohio 25
Kent led this game the entire way and Ohio got within 8 with a TD with 3 minutes left to make it somewhat close. Kent out-played Ohio from the line of scrimmage 5.4 yppl to 5.1 yppl but were +2 in turnovers. This one could have gone either way if the turnovers were even (based on the yppl differential) so I'll all it a toss-up even though Kent never trailed. Toss up - Winner.
***Houston (-11) 35 East Carolina 37
Wrong side - Loser.
****Rutgers (-16 ½) 24 Maryland 34
Rutgers out gained Maryland 5.9 yppl to 5.5 yppl and were -3 in turnovers, but this was a bad call. Wrong side - Loser.
**New Mexico (+5 ½) 24 Byu 31
New Mexico is not a turnover prone team, but the Lobos committed 5 turnovers (one returned for a BYU touchdown) and were -3 in turnover margin in this game. The Lobos out played BYU 5.0 yppl to 4.8 yppl and had the game covered despite the negative turnover margin before BYU kicked a field goal with 4 minutes left. When a dog out plays the favorite from the line of scrimmage and still nearly covers despite being -3 in turnover margin it is a good bet. Right side - Loser.
**Florida International (+11) 6 Mid Tennessee St 47
Wrong side - Loser.
***Kentucky (-22) 45 Florida Atlantic 17
The game covering TD came on an interception return, but Kentucky dominated the game from the line of scrimmage 504 yards at 6.9 yppl to 307 yards at 4.9 yppl. This one could have gone either way. Toss up - Winner.
Week 6
**Southern Miss (-20 ½) 29 Rice 31
Southern Miss was forced to play their injured backup quarterback when the healthy 3rd string QB was hurt in the first series of the game. Bad luck that the only healthy quarterback on the roster gets hurt and even worse luck when and injured QB has to play and turns the ball over 7 times and can't throw more than 15 yards down the field. Southern Miss still out-gained Rice 422 yards (at 5.1 yppl) to 240 yards at 4.0 yppl. To turn the ball over 7 times (to 2 turnover for Rice) and only lose by 2 points is an indication of how much better Southern Miss is. I have no doubt that Southern Miss would have had a very good chance to win by 21 points or more with a healthy quarterback or even with an injured one as long as he didn't turn it over 7 times. Southern Miss covers this game more than not if they play it 100 times, so I'll put this into the toss-up category. Toss up - Loser.
**Michigan St (-14 ½) 41 Northwestern 48
Wrong side - Loser.
**Auburn (-7) 35 Vanderbilt 7
This game became a Best Bet on Saturday morning when the line went down to -7 at 8:50 am. Auburn dominated the game 7.1 yppl to 3.2 yppl. Right side - Winner.
***Nebraska (+7) 6 Missouri 41
Wrong side - Loser.
***Georgia (+1) 14 Tennessee 35
Wrong side - Loser.
**Arizona (+4) 16 Oregon State 31
Wrong side - Loser.
***Georgia Tech (-2 ½) 26 Maryland 28
Georgia Tech out-gained Maryland 484 yards to 345 yard, but the yards per play was more telling (as it usually is) at 6.3 yppl for Georgia Tech to 6.7 yppl for Maryland. This game could have gone either way based on the huge total yards advantage and close yards per play and even turnovers. Toss up - Loser.
***Florida (+7 ½) 24 Lsu 28
Florida was up by 10 point entering the 4th quarter and out-gained LSU 5.5 yppl to 4.9 yppl and covered despite a -1 turnover margin. LSU took the lead with one minute left in the game and had no chance to cover this game. Right side - Winner.
****UCLA (-20 ½) 6 Notre Dame 20
UCLA's defense held Notre Dame's pathetic offense to just 147 total yards at 2.3 yppl and would have held them to 3 points and would have had a decent chance to cover if not for the injury to starting quarterback Ben Olson. That forced 3rd string quarterback Bethel-Thompson into the game and he committed 7 turnovers. I still think UCLA would have had a good chance to cover if not for the injury to Olson because Notre Dame's offense was not going to score more than 3 points without the turnovers. But, I'll put this into the category of the wrong side. Wrong side - Loser.
Week 7
**Buffalo (-3 ½) 43 Toledo 33
Buffalo jumped out to a 36-13 lead and out-gained the Rockets 7.4 yppl to 5.3 yppl for the game. The turnovers were even and Buffalo was clearly the better team. Right side - Winner.
****Houston (-21) 56 Rice 48
Houston out gained Rice by an incredible 750 yards at 9.5 yards per play to 441 yards at 5.7 yppl. Such a yardage and yppl differential would be expected to win by 30 points or so but Houston committed two turnovers on kickoff returns that led to short Rice TD drives, had another turnover at their own 5 yard line setting up and easy score and then fumbled on 1st and goal at the one yard line and fumbled to keep them from leading at the half. Those 4 turnovers led directly to 28 points and Houston only won by 8 points despite scoring every time they didn't turn the ball over. Right side - Loser.
**Illinois (-3 ½) 6 Iowa 10
Illinois is a much better team than Iowa and out-gained the Hawkeyes 5.2 yppl to 4.7 yppl, which is what you'd expect from a small favorite. Illinois was -1 in turnover margin. Toss up - Loser.
**Air Force (+3 ½) 45 Colorado State 21
Air Force was +3 in turnover margin, but the Falcons didn't need the turnovers to win this game (out-gained CSU 5.9 yppl to 5.3 yppl as a dog). Right side - Winner.
***Texas Tech (-8 ½) 35 Texas A&M 7
Texas Tech dominated the stats and the scoreboard and turnovers were not a factor (1 each). Right side - Winner.
****Oklahoma (-10 ½) 41 Missouri 31
Oklahoma missed 4 extra points and Missouri scored a touchdown with 12 seconds left in the game to cover by ½ a point with a TD that replays showed was clearly not a TD (why no review?). Oklahoma did catch some breaks during the course of the game and were +2 in turnovers (one for a TD), but the Sooners also out-played Missouri 5.9 yppl to 5.3 yppl. This one goes into the toss-up category. Toss up - Loser.
Week 8
***Memphis (+2) 38 Rice 35
Rice scored a TD with 2 minutes remaining to make this game close, but Memphis out-gained the Owls 571 yards at 6.4 yppl to 418 yards at 6.4 yppl. The yppl were even in a near pick em game, so I'll have to call this a toss up. Toss up - Winner.
****Ohio State (-17 ½) 24 Michigan State 17
Ohio State was cruising along with a 24-0 lead and dominating on both sides of the ball when Michigan State picked off a pass and ran it in for 54 yard touchdown return. A few plays later the Buckeyes fumbles and that ball was run back for a TD too. After those two events coach Tressel got real conservative in his play calling because he knew his defense was not going to give up a touchdown drive. The only way Michigan State was going to score a touchdown was on turnover returns as the Buckeyes held the Spartans to just 185 total yards at 3.6 yppl. If Ohio State simply turned the ball over twice their defense would have stopped Michigan State from scoring, but each turnover was returned for a touchdown. Ohio State racked up 424 total yards at 6.1 yppl and should have won this game by at least 21 points. Second week in a row I had the right side in a 4-Star and lost. Right side - Loser.
**Fresno State (-12 ½) 30 San Jose State 0
Right side - Winner.
***Illinois (+2 ½) 17 Michigan 27
This game was tied at 17 midway through the 4th quarter and Michigan only out gained Illinois 4.5 yppl to 4.4 yppl. While the stats suggest this game could have gone either way, I watched this game and thought Michigan was the better team. Wrong side - Loser.
**Troy (-19 ½) 45 North Texas 7
Complete domination. Troy won by 38 points despite turning the ball over 7 times and being -5 in turnovers. Right side - Winner.
Week 9
**Virginia Tech (-3) 10 Boston College 14
Virginia Tech's defense dominated this game for 3 ½ quarters before BC got a touchdown to push the spread with 2 minutes left. I was upset to have to settle for a push at the time but BC recovered the onside kick and scored with 11 seconds left. The onside kick recovery went right at a Virginia Tech player who muffed it. That's pretty random bad luck as a push turned into an unlucky loss. Toss up - Loser.
**New Mexico (-6) 34 Air Force 31
New Mexico's kick, who had made 18 consecutive field goals, missed an easy 32 yarder in the final minutes to keep me from pushing this game. But, New Mexico was out-played from the line of scrimmage and were +3 in turnovers (5 Air Force fumbles), so this goes down a bad bet. Wrong side - Loser.
***Wisconsin (-7 ½) 33 Indiana 3
Right side - Winner.
**Auburn (-17) 17 Mississippi 3
Auburn out-gained Ole Miss 420 yards to 193 yards and should have scored more than 17 points. Toss up - Loser.
***Kansas (-2 ½) 19 Texas A&M 11
Kansas led 19-0 with 8 minutes left before A&M made a late run. The Jayhawks easily won the stats. Right side - Winner.
**Marshall (-8) 34 Rice 21
Marshall was up 17-0 at the half before Rice made a run. Marshall out-gained Rice 481 yards at 6.1 yppl to 428 yards at 5.6 yppl and Rice got most of their yards after the game was decided. Right side - Winner.
***Hawaii (-27 ½) 50 New Mexico State 13
Hawaii out-played New Mexico State 8.4 yards per play to 5.1 yppl and had the game covered late before an interception return TD sealed the deal. This game really could have gone either way. Toss-up - Winner.
Week 10
***Ohio (-7 ½) 23 Temple 7
Ohio dominated this game 405 yards at 5.9 yppl to 209 yards at 3.7 yppl and didn't need the +2 in turnover margin to cover. Right side - Winner.
**Arkansas (-4 ½) 48 South Carolina 36
Arkansas racked up 650 total yards at 9.4 yppl while South Carolina averaged only 5.9 yppl. Right side - Winner.
**Penn State (-7) 26 Purdue 19
Purdue scored a TD on the opening kick off but Penn State dominated as expected and built a 26-16 lead, which would have been 27-16 if not for a botched extra point attempt. Purdue added a late field goal to make it a 7 point game and a frustrating push. Penn State had 461 yards at 6.1 yppl to Purdue's 323 yards at 4.5 yppl and would have covered despite the kickoff return TD if they didn't miss that extra point. Right side - Push.
Week 11
***Air Force (-3) 41 Notre Dame 24
Air Force dominated this game 407 yards at 5.2 yppl to 304 yards at just 3.9 yppl for Notre Dame. Right side - Winner.
Virginia Tech (-6) 40 Florida State 21
Both teams had interception return TD's and the Florida State was up by 1 point heading into the 4th quarter but Virginia Tech dominated the final quarter and finished the game with a 398 yards (at 5.6 yppl) to 267 yards (at 4.4 yppl) advantage. Right side - Winner.
**Southern Miss (-15 ½) 26 Memphis 29
Wrong side - Loser.
**Florida (-6 ½) 51 South Carolina 31
Florida has a 537 yards (at 6.7 yppl) to 384 yards (at 5.7 yppl) advantage and turnovers were even. An easy winner. Right side - Winner.
Week 12
**Nevada (+7) 26 Hawaii 28
Nevada was up on the spread by two touchdowns before Hawaii scored with 11 seconds left in the game to win straight up. Nevada covered despite being -2 in turnover margin due to 2 lost fumbles. Right side - Winner.
**Clemson (-7 ½) 17 Boston College 20
Wrong side - Loser.
***Washington State (-2 ½) 17 Oregon State 52
This game was actually pretty close in yardage and yards per play but Washington State was -8 in turnover margin. Wrong side - Loser.
****South Florida (-7) 55 Louisville 17
South Florida was +7 in turnovers, but they also out-played Louisville from the line of scrimmage 6.4 yppl to 5.5 yppl. This game should have been closer than it was, but South Florida was certainly the right side and would have won by more than 7 points without the turnover advantage. Right side - Winner.
Week 13
**Arizona State (+3) 24 USC 44
Wrong side - Loser.
***LSU (-12) 48 Arkansas 50
Wrong side - Loser.
***Pittsburgh (+10) 37 South Florida 48
Pitt out-gained USF 393 yards at 5.5 yppl to 352 yards at 5.3 yppl but the Bulls returned two interceptions for touchdowns. When a double-digit dog outplays the favorite from the line of scrimmage you're supposed to win. Right side - Loser.
**West Virginia (-17 ½) 66 Connecticut 21
West Virginia with 624 total yards at 9.6 yppl to 392 yards at 4.7 yppl for U Conn. Right side - Winner.
***North Carolina (-14) 20 Duke 14
Wrong side - Loser.
***Miami-Ohio (+2) 29 Ohio 38
Miami-Ohio dominated Ohio 379 yards at 4.4 yppl to 199 yards at 3.6 yppl and they were the underdog. Ohio had a kickoff return TD and a turnover advantage. Miami was certainly the right side in this game. Right side - Loser.
***Alabama (+6) 10 Auburn 17
This game was tight the entire way and Auburn scored the spread covering TD with 3:58 left in the game. Toss up - Loser.
**Stanford (-3 ½) 14 Notre Dame 21
Notre Dame broke a 14-14 tie with about 9 minutes left and Stanford receivers dropped 2 touchdown passes on the last two plays that would have sent the game to OT and given me a chance to win. Still, Notre Dame out played the Cardinal from the line of scrimmage 4.7 yppl to 4.2 yppl so I deserved to lose. Wrong Side - Loser.