I'll shut up if someone can give me one good reason to post a play with no accompanying explanation.
i don't know if these are necessarily "good reasons" in your view, but i can tell you why i do it and will continue to do it...
1 -- i play a lot of plays, probably 4 or 5 daily on average. with 7-8 months of nba, it would be absolutely ridiculous to write up every play from a time perspective...simply don't have the time most days to do it.
2 -- a lot of my reasoning behind the plays would sound redundant because i have a certain way of capping just like anyone else. i've been on this forum for 2 years and others prior to that for a few years. the people who actually read my plays on a regular basis usually infer why i like a play just because they've seen my discuss games or do writeups in the past and it fits with the way i cap. i respect the opinions of several people on the site and have a sense of which side they will be on for the most part...if a certain play they post is not consistent with what i think they usually do, i try to ask why they like the play because i didn't expect it/don't agree with it, etc
3 -- it's an easy way to keep your own record. i keep my record several different ways and in a more complex way at this point, but this is the way i had originally started keeping a record and i still use this for simplicity
4 -- combined with number 1, several times i have done writeups on 5 or 6 plays and have gotten absolutely no feedback because i'm not a guy like bar who gets a lot of views/reads, which makes sense because i'm not nearly as good as he is, but it doesn't make sense for me to put time into writeups if there is no feedback or counterpoints
i post plays and when people post disagreements or even are curious as to why i like a certain play, 99 out of 100 times i will respond with at least something even if it's short. that method has worked for me, and it's the most efficient for me and i'll continue to do it that way regardless of the number of smartass comments that show up in my thread and other threads about posting plays only.
whenever i've had the time to contribute to the discussion thread i've found it very helpful and informative. i was discussing two losing plays the other day in a discussion thread and when they both failed to cash i had 100 reasons why they didn't just from arguing with people in that thread...so i definitely do find value in the discussion thread even if it is just a handful of people...
:shake: