rank these pitchers

[Tide High]

from here on out

CC
Lackey
Lincecum
Volquez
Lee


and would you trade Brandon Phillips straight up for any of them?

 

[RetroVK]

lackey
lincecum
cc
volquez
lee

phillips question is a "need" question. pretty good 2b though.

 

[reNew Orleans]

definitely not cliff lee

 

[Tide High]

i have kinsler at 2B. at this point they are about even. losing power for SB by trading philips over kinsler.

 

[Tide High]

and y es i NEED SP

 

[Tide High]

i think i'd go for Lincecum or Lackey for Phillips or Kinsler.

 

[RetroVK]

if you are set at 2b like that and need a SP then its ok. Since they are about even i would likely research who is more injury prone.

 

[Fondybadger]

from here on out

CC
Lackey
Lincecum
Volquez
Lee


and would you trade Brandon Phillips straight up for any of them?

Lackey
Lincecum
Volquez
CC
Lee

Yes, get yourself a pitcher

 

[wreck]

Lackey
CC
Lincecum/Volquez
Lee

 

[Tide High]

sent phillips for lackey, and he sent back quentin + Lackey for Phillips + ludwick. isn't that too much? or can anyone see quentin doing better than ludwick from here on out?

 

[Tide High]

fuck it i accepted. i hate giving in to this asshole because he's been trying to get steals off me all year, but quinten and ludwick are the same IMO. i guess he likes ludwick better, but quinten is in a better park. can't see a real diff so i guess i should just accept it and watch ludwick become the mvp 2nd half

 

[Moneyline_Monster]

From a fantasy perspective:
Lackey
Lincecum
CC
Volquez
Lee

 

[Fondybadger]

I'd prefer Quentin actually... and Lackey was the best of the group when giving up Phillips.

 

[Tide High]

thanks fellas. i've gone from 12/12 to 7/12 with 5 straight winning weeks. let's hope this trade continues that success.