Player Comparison: How much better is...

[B.A.R.]

Josh Allen...

OVER


John Elway

?

Thoughts?

 

[RetroVK]

This is pretty clear given Allen has proven more, plays in an era where the rules are heavily tilted against QB's and the passing game, and has played against much stiffer competition.

Why are we having this discussion? Is someone questioning the obvious fact that Allen is superior to Elway?

 

[takeit]

Elway himself seems to like Allen - so there's that. Can't wait for us to give up an arm and a leg for him!

 

[rambler882]

Allen is more handsome so there is something to that.

 

[takeit]

Allen is more handsome so there is something to that.

True. But it's not saying much.

 

[VirginiaCavs]

Ability to make adjustments at the los. Experience in pro style offense. Arm. Prototypical size. Mobility for size. Playmaker despite lack of supporting cast. It factor.

Elway lost to an expansion team in the playoffs.

Josh Allen over Jack Elway

 

[KJ]

Josh Allen over Joan Allen. Tighter spiral but just barely.

 

[VirginiaCavs]

Josh Allen over Dante Culpepper Donovan Mcnabb Warren Moon Lamar Jackson Michael Vick Steve McNair Cam Newton Russell Wilson