Keeper help please

[Tide High]

Just cant decide...

Standard scoring 14 teamer. 4pt pass tds. 2 flex spots

11th pick

Ray rice (1st)
Peyton (5th)

Players kept:
Ap
Foster
Doug
Rg3
Wilson
Calvin
Arod
Andre brown
Sjax
Demaryus thomas
Ridley
Alfred

My.pick, if I.dont keep rice will actually be 9th & 14th. If I do, its 13th.

sewms like ray is standard but am really considering peyton. Im basically looking at

Rice and a player like ant brown/bradshaw (late 5th in 14 team keeper)
Vs
Peyton and mjd/dez

 

[Tide High]

The slash is or. Depending on rb or wr

 

[reNew Orleans]

i dont quite follow
you have the 11th pick

if you dont keep rice you'll get the 9th and 14th
if you keep rice you get the 11th and 13th
?

I think if you keep rice, anotnio brown easy.
peyton then you can go either way.

 

[Tide High]

sorry, typed on phone shouldn't have.

i am 11 out of 14 in draft order but because of keepers i am actually the 9th overall pick IF i DON'T keep Rice (and DO keep Manning).

if i DO keep Rice I don't have a 1st round pick so my pick is 13th overall (2nd rounder - i have this pick in 2nd round either way).

with the other players i listed, i was just throwing out a scenario.

 

[eggman]

Yeah, I'm still pretty confused, but I think you're saying that you would be picking 9th overall because there are 2 people in front of you keeping players with their first round pick, correct? Quite honestly, assuming that I understand your draft properly, you'd keep Rice with your first round pick and Manning with your 5th round pick? Well if that is the case, I don't know why you wouldn't keep both, I see value in both, especially Manning in the 5th. In a 14 man league there is no way he makes it that long without getting picked again, and he should be good for 4k and 35TD's this year I would think.

 

[Tide High]

Yeah, I'm still pretty confused, but I think you're saying that you would be picking 9th overall because there are 2 people in front of you keeping players with their first round pick, correct? Quite honestly, assuming that I understand your draft properly, you'd keep Rice with your first round pick and Manning with your 5th round pick? Well if that is the case, I don't know why you wouldn't keep both, I see value in both, especially Manning in the 5th. In a 14 man league there is no way he makes it that long without getting picked again, and he should be good for 4k and 35TD's this year I would think.

i must be the worst communicator. i feel sorry for my coworkers.

its rice or manning. thanks for the input in advance.

others chime in too please

 

[Tide High]

but yes you have everything else correct.

 

[Tide High]

can only keep 1. draft in 7 hours

 

[Lareux]

can only keep 1. draft in 7 hours

Another draft that's at least 2 weeks too early. Good luck Tide, hope you draft well. I would keep Rice, but if losing that 1st round pick means that much to you it's best to keep Peyton.

 

[KowboyKarl]

I would go either way...I guess pick the the player you like/wanna root for most.

 

[mcdrewcarey187]

If you keep Peyton you would have 2 picks right? So couldn't you potentially get mjd and Dez? I'd rather have MJD Dez and Peyton than Rice, Bradshaw and the equivalent of a 6th rounder in a 14 team league. Am I reading this correct?

 

[orangemonk]

^ that. Peyton for sure, give up that 5th round pick

 

[madshooter]

no brainer, you gotta keep Rice IMO.....the QB position will have tons of depth plus you may find a QB that also runs for TD's which will be far more valuable than Peyton who is 1 hit away from retirement. Rice is still a top 5 RB.

 

[eggman]

Mad shooter, I agree on the. qB depth comment. Hopefully went with Rice.

 

[Tide High]

Good commentary. Stuck with rice bc I was worried my best rb would be mjd. My qb is now tannehill lol