NYGiants25
NY Giants fan, anyone?
Best CFB Week 1 bets
College football season is back, which means that our betting experts are as well. Every Thursday, our CFB experts -- Phil Steele, Stanford Steve and Chris Fallica -- will pick two common games and then as many wild-card games as they choose. It's all here in one file, for your perusing pleasure.
Here are the best bets for Week 1 of the college football season.
Note: Lines from Westgate SuperBook as of Wednesday morning.
Common games
No. 1 Alabama Crimson Tide (-7) vs. No. 3 Florida State Seminoles at Atlanta, Georgia
Steele: This is the highest-ranked matchup ever for an opening week with No. 1 versus No. 3, and I believe it will live up to its billing. The talent is stacked on both sides of the ball with NFL-caliber players, as all the units are ranked in my top 25 unit rankings. Alabama's biggest edge may be with the stronger offensive line; Florida State has the special teams edge. The Seminoles only lose three lettermen off last year's defense and get back Derwin James, who missed almost all of 2016 due to an injury. He may be the nation's top defensive player.
Nick Saban is 9-0 versus his former assistants, but he has yet to face one that has won a national title. This game could go either way and I will side with a very talented underdog getting a full touchdown.
ATS pick: Florida State
Score: Alabama 26, Florida State 23
Fallica: While it isn't a game I would be running to play, if I had to I would simply say to myself: At some point I just need to trust Nick Saban in this type of season-opener.
In five previous season-openers at Alabama versus ranked opponents -- three coming against Top-10 teams -- Saban's team has won all five by double digits. Who knows how the week will play out, but at the time of writing, FSU WR Auden Tate is nursing an injury and LB Matthew Thomas' status is in doubt. Will the FSU offensive line be any better? It better be as Deondre Francois took a beating last year, getting sacked 34 times, including six times against Clemson. If the WR core is basically Noonie Murray and a couple of unproven guys and you're relying on a combo of a true freshman (Cam Akers) and Jacques Patrick and a questionable offensive line to score points against Alabama, that's a problem.
The FSU defense improved dramatically as the year went on, but I think based on what we know right now, Alabama has more answers on offense and is the safer play. One will never look foolish for picking Alabama to win a football game.
ATS pick: Alabama
Score: Alabama 31, Florida State 21
Coughlin: I think the storyline of Nick Saban facing his former LSU assistant Jimbo Fisher is being a little overblown, seeing as how they do not stay that in touch -- Fisher said the last time they chatted was at the NFL draft. That said, I think it should be pointed out that Saban is 8-2 ATS vs. former assistants -- that's enough for me to lean in the direction of the Tide.
It also seems to me, as I read some of the articles out of Tallahassee, that the 'Noles might be coming into the game not at full strength -- injuries are starting to pile up. Alabama comes in with more proven guys in the playmaking category, with Jalen Hurts (Saban's first returning starter at QB since 2013) and RB Bo Scarborough, who rushed for over 800 yards in 2016.
Last season, Alabama scored 15 non-offensive touchdowns, which led the country. While I'm not saying that the Crimson Tide will repeat that effort in 2017, I like being on the side of the team where those types of things happen, and they happen because of the way Saban prepares his team. I'm giving the points.
ATS pick: Alabama
Score: Alabama 28, Florida State 17
No. 11 Michigan Wolverines (-3.5) vs. No. 17 Florida Gators at Arlington, Texas
Steele: Michigan has the fewest returning starters in the country (five) and its young team (No. 128 in my experience chart) is away from home. Florida has 14 returning starters and beat Georgia, LSU and Iowa away from home last year. The Gators have slight edges on offense and defense and a bigger edge on special teams (No. 3 versus No. 38). Florida is a top-10 team in my rankings and I think Michigan will be playing its best football at the end of the year. The Gators have eight suspended players, including two starters, but their special teams and experience edge will help them pull off the upset in Arlington, Texas.
ATS pick: Florida
Score: Florida 27, Michigan 24
Fallica: We really don't know much about either offense here, as Michigan will no longer have RB De'Veon Smith and every productive WR/TE from last year. Florida has its own unknowns at QB and will not have Antonio Calloway and others because of suspension. McElwain's decision here is interesting: Does he go with the guy who has started some at Notre Dame, but only recently arrived in Gainesville (Malik Zaire), or does he go with Feleipe Franks, who has no playing experience but has been in Gainesville for two years now.
I do think Michigan is a tad underrated entering the season. That defensive line with Maurice Hurst and Rashan Gary should be nasty and help take some pressure off an inexperienced secondary. And Don Brown's track record suggests he'll figure it out. If Florida does indeed have the best offensive line in the SEC, they will need to play like it here.
Much like the Alabama-Florida State game, I wouldn't be running to a window to play this one, as it's a total toss-up game where no result would really surprise me. But because I have to make a pick, I'll go with the favorite in a really good, competitive game.
ATS pick: Michigan
Score: Michigan 28, Florida 24
Coughlin: If you like two teams who just line up and try to knock each other around, this should be a fantastic game to watch.
We know about the Florida suspensions. We've read plenty about the teams' back-and-forth over proper pre-game depth chart and roster releases. Florida has not announced its starting QB, and I can't believe how many opinions there are on who it will be. Does the 41-7 butt-whipping Michigan gave the Gators in the Citrus Bowl after the 2015 season mean anything? All items worth considering.
While the Gators only return five starters on defense, there are plenty of guys coming back who played a ton at the end of the 2016 season, when the team was struck by injuries. The idea of Michigan losing all that defensive talent (10 starters on defense) seems a bit much to me against a tough opponent in Week 1. I also think Wilton Speight and the Wolverines offense will take a little time to jell, and will really miss Jake Butt and their two other top pass-catchers from a year ago. I'll take the points in a tough game.
ATS pick: Florida
Score: Michigan 12, Florida 10
College football season is back, which means that our betting experts are as well. Every Thursday, our CFB experts -- Phil Steele, Stanford Steve and Chris Fallica -- will pick two common games and then as many wild-card games as they choose. It's all here in one file, for your perusing pleasure.
Here are the best bets for Week 1 of the college football season.
Note: Lines from Westgate SuperBook as of Wednesday morning.
Common games
No. 1 Alabama Crimson Tide (-7) vs. No. 3 Florida State Seminoles at Atlanta, Georgia
Steele: This is the highest-ranked matchup ever for an opening week with No. 1 versus No. 3, and I believe it will live up to its billing. The talent is stacked on both sides of the ball with NFL-caliber players, as all the units are ranked in my top 25 unit rankings. Alabama's biggest edge may be with the stronger offensive line; Florida State has the special teams edge. The Seminoles only lose three lettermen off last year's defense and get back Derwin James, who missed almost all of 2016 due to an injury. He may be the nation's top defensive player.
Nick Saban is 9-0 versus his former assistants, but he has yet to face one that has won a national title. This game could go either way and I will side with a very talented underdog getting a full touchdown.
ATS pick: Florida State
Score: Alabama 26, Florida State 23
Fallica: While it isn't a game I would be running to play, if I had to I would simply say to myself: At some point I just need to trust Nick Saban in this type of season-opener.
In five previous season-openers at Alabama versus ranked opponents -- three coming against Top-10 teams -- Saban's team has won all five by double digits. Who knows how the week will play out, but at the time of writing, FSU WR Auden Tate is nursing an injury and LB Matthew Thomas' status is in doubt. Will the FSU offensive line be any better? It better be as Deondre Francois took a beating last year, getting sacked 34 times, including six times against Clemson. If the WR core is basically Noonie Murray and a couple of unproven guys and you're relying on a combo of a true freshman (Cam Akers) and Jacques Patrick and a questionable offensive line to score points against Alabama, that's a problem.
The FSU defense improved dramatically as the year went on, but I think based on what we know right now, Alabama has more answers on offense and is the safer play. One will never look foolish for picking Alabama to win a football game.
ATS pick: Alabama
Score: Alabama 31, Florida State 21
Coughlin: I think the storyline of Nick Saban facing his former LSU assistant Jimbo Fisher is being a little overblown, seeing as how they do not stay that in touch -- Fisher said the last time they chatted was at the NFL draft. That said, I think it should be pointed out that Saban is 8-2 ATS vs. former assistants -- that's enough for me to lean in the direction of the Tide.
It also seems to me, as I read some of the articles out of Tallahassee, that the 'Noles might be coming into the game not at full strength -- injuries are starting to pile up. Alabama comes in with more proven guys in the playmaking category, with Jalen Hurts (Saban's first returning starter at QB since 2013) and RB Bo Scarborough, who rushed for over 800 yards in 2016.
Last season, Alabama scored 15 non-offensive touchdowns, which led the country. While I'm not saying that the Crimson Tide will repeat that effort in 2017, I like being on the side of the team where those types of things happen, and they happen because of the way Saban prepares his team. I'm giving the points.
ATS pick: Alabama
Score: Alabama 28, Florida State 17
No. 11 Michigan Wolverines (-3.5) vs. No. 17 Florida Gators at Arlington, Texas
Steele: Michigan has the fewest returning starters in the country (five) and its young team (No. 128 in my experience chart) is away from home. Florida has 14 returning starters and beat Georgia, LSU and Iowa away from home last year. The Gators have slight edges on offense and defense and a bigger edge on special teams (No. 3 versus No. 38). Florida is a top-10 team in my rankings and I think Michigan will be playing its best football at the end of the year. The Gators have eight suspended players, including two starters, but their special teams and experience edge will help them pull off the upset in Arlington, Texas.
ATS pick: Florida
Score: Florida 27, Michigan 24
Fallica: We really don't know much about either offense here, as Michigan will no longer have RB De'Veon Smith and every productive WR/TE from last year. Florida has its own unknowns at QB and will not have Antonio Calloway and others because of suspension. McElwain's decision here is interesting: Does he go with the guy who has started some at Notre Dame, but only recently arrived in Gainesville (Malik Zaire), or does he go with Feleipe Franks, who has no playing experience but has been in Gainesville for two years now.
I do think Michigan is a tad underrated entering the season. That defensive line with Maurice Hurst and Rashan Gary should be nasty and help take some pressure off an inexperienced secondary. And Don Brown's track record suggests he'll figure it out. If Florida does indeed have the best offensive line in the SEC, they will need to play like it here.
Much like the Alabama-Florida State game, I wouldn't be running to a window to play this one, as it's a total toss-up game where no result would really surprise me. But because I have to make a pick, I'll go with the favorite in a really good, competitive game.
ATS pick: Michigan
Score: Michigan 28, Florida 24
Coughlin: If you like two teams who just line up and try to knock each other around, this should be a fantastic game to watch.
We know about the Florida suspensions. We've read plenty about the teams' back-and-forth over proper pre-game depth chart and roster releases. Florida has not announced its starting QB, and I can't believe how many opinions there are on who it will be. Does the 41-7 butt-whipping Michigan gave the Gators in the Citrus Bowl after the 2015 season mean anything? All items worth considering.
While the Gators only return five starters on defense, there are plenty of guys coming back who played a ton at the end of the 2016 season, when the team was struck by injuries. The idea of Michigan losing all that defensive talent (10 starters on defense) seems a bit much to me against a tough opponent in Week 1. I also think Wilton Speight and the Wolverines offense will take a little time to jell, and will really miss Jake Butt and their two other top pass-catchers from a year ago. I'll take the points in a tough game.
ATS pick: Florida
Score: Michigan 12, Florida 10