Vandy +4 to win 1 unit
This is an interesting game and I think a lot of people are going with miami. But I don't really see why, this team is predicted to be one of the worst teams in the MAC. They have a weak home field crowd, and I could see this being one of those games were its sort of like "this is where the MAC proves they can beat a BCS team". They were 2-4 last year at home while Vandy was a decent 2-2 on the road. I think Vandy probably wins this game out right and possibly in a blowout.
That stats are misleading because the SEC and MAC are completely diffrent leagues...Vandy averaged 34 points a game against non SEC opponents and Miami was giving up 37 points a game against non MAC opponents. This seems like a game which a lot of people jump on Miami because Vandy kind of sucked, but no matter which way you looked at it, Miami had 1 more win then Vandy in a much weaker conference, I think Vandy wins, but if they lose 17-14 thats fine with me too. GL Broadway
GL - marlo
GL - Bar
GL - dwight
hey alex....don't take it the wrong way or anything because i'm not trying to change your mind, but just trying to make sure you're looking at the right information and playing some devil's advocate...
first of all, miami is not predicted to finish one of the worst teams in the MAC by anyone that i've read, in fact they are the favorites of many including myself to return to the MAC championship...they return nearly all of a defense that ranked 25 against the pass with a solid secondary and ability to rush the passer along with 3 returning lbs.
they finished the regular season with a crushing loss to ohio that kept them out of a bowl game...and by crushing, i mean crushing. that is a game they led 17-7 at the half. radabaugh threw 2 picks that led to ohio tds on the first two possessions. miami stalled on FIVE drives in that game that led to fgs...yes, five fgs and they went on to lose the game. they outgained ohio by 190 yards and lost. that was the difference between a winning season bowl game and a losing season...which leads to an enormous amount of hunger in week 1 of the following season.
they have some definite weaknesses, yes, but their qb with ability comes back and should have at least a little more time behind an oline that was pretty shitty last year. they've been working on quicker passes so that he can get the ball out quicker. this will help him with his mistakes (many of which were forced by the oline) which is another area of concern. he's reportedly had a good camp though, he's talented, and i think the most improved unit on this team will be his receivers, most of which were freshmen last year. rb and oline is still going to be vulnerable, but i think they can cover it up with their passing game and very good defense. fact is, they definitely won't be one of the worst teams in the MAC this year, and i think they will be much improved overall. vandy may win this game, but i am extremely confident it won't be a blowout...at least on the vandy side...
as far as misleading stats, yes...two very different leagues...BUT you compared two very different out of conference schedules in your next thought....
first of all, i came up with different numbers than you did (let me know if i'm mistaken here):
vandy out of conf scoring:
richmond 41
eastern michigan 30
miami oh 24
wake 17
=28 ppg
miami out of conf defense = i did get 34 ppg (not 37, again let me know if i'm wrong) but against minn (IN DOUBLE OT), cinci and colorado (which would both frankly kick the shit out of both of these teams and did just that to miami), vandy (which we'll get to later), and cuse (who they beat in a game that i think will be similar to this one 17-14)
now you pointed out a couple of times the difference in leagues, then you compare out of conference schedules which are obviously lopsided...richmond and eastern michigan??? i would hope they'd score on those two teams...
not only that, but this was last year's vandy's offense...this year it's not even close to the offense it was imo. they lose their ENTIRE line...whenever that happens it is a negative thing, especially in week 1, and especially when you had a tackle go that was taken in the first round in the draft. the team also lost a considerable amount on defense. the players that do return cannot be nearly as hungry as miami is...last year was their year to do something imo...coming into last year vandy had i believe 18 returning starters and had lost FOUR sec games by a td or less...they had a weak out of conf schedule and last year was supposed to be the year they got it done. things obviously didn't go as planned, and now the most significant returning players are at qb (2 of em who both played pretty inconsistent last year), and in the secondary. In addition to the oline and the pairs of lbs and dts they lose, they also lose their top receiver and top rb...basically it is a very different team this year and an inferior one. one advantage they do have is that they should be able to get to radabaugh and they have a pretty good secondary even if they don't every play...which is why i'm also on the under because i believe the same is true when vandy is on offense.
now let's take a look at last year's game...
24-13. ok. so with all the above, i feel pretty confident that vandy does not get to 24. a pretty close game at vandy's place. you flip the homefield, which i disagree that you state homefield doesn't matter in this game because of what you call a weak home crowd, but that's obviously opinionated and debatable on both ends so we'll leave that out of this...
midway through the 3rd quarter with vandy having undoubtedly a better offense than they have this year, and miami having undoubtedly a better defense THIS year than last, miami led 13-10 on the road. the game came down to exactly one thing....earl bennett going off and being unstoppable. he had 215 yard of receiving that game on 8 catches. vandy does not return earl bennett. also in that game, adams who took over during the year as the starter, got injured allowing the better passer nickson to come in and miami was not preparing for him. so miami has the confidence they need here on both sides of the ball, especially being at home, and they won't see anything that they haven't seen before or weren't expecting. the only thing they will see is a lot less talent across from them as they did last year.
so those are the reasons that i have for making my miami and my under wagers on this game...and as far as a lot of people jumping on miami here, i must be looking at something different there too, because i'm actually seeing some reverse line movement here with up to 62% on vandy on some sites (very "public" for a dog) and the line moving nearly a fg the other way. and this makes logical sense, because i think a lot of people have that sec vs mac stigma attached to their thought processes....
just my .02 alex...as always take with a grain of salt...gl on the rest of your card bud